Case 19377

Case Overview
Application of:   The Boundary Companies and The Missionary Society
Case Summary:   Application of The Boundary Companies and The Missionary Society of St Paul the Apostle, as amended, pursuant to 11 DCMR Subtitle X, Chapter 9 for special exceptions under the theoretical lot subdivision requirements of Subtitle C § 305.1, the roof structure requirements of Subtitle C § 1500.4, and the new residential development requirements of Subtitle U § 421, and pursuant to 11 DCMR Subtitle X, Chapter 10, variances from the vehicular access requirements and the RA-1 Zone development standards of Subtitle C § 305.3, to construct 60 row dwellings and a new clerical residential building in the RA-1 Zone at premises 3015 4th Street N.E. (Square 3648, Lot 915).
Application of The Boundary Companies and The Missionary Society of St Paul the Apostle, as amended, pursuant to 11 DCMR Subtitle X, Chapter 9 for special exceptions under the theoretical lot subdivision requirements of Subtitle C § 305.1, the roof structure requirements of Subtitle C § 1500.4, and the new residential development requirements of Subtitle U § 421, and pursuant to 11 DCMR Subtitle X, Chapter 10, variances from the vehicular access requirements and the RA-1 Zone development standards of Subtitle C § 305.3, to construct 60 row dwellings and a new clerical residential building in the RA-1 Zone at premises 3015 4th Street N.E. (Square 3648, Lot 915).
Address:  
ANC:   5E01
Relief:  
Pursuant To:  
Case Type:   Special Exception
Case Status:   Closed
Result:   Approved 5 - 0 - 0
Past Hearing Date(s):   05/23/2018
Past Meeting Date(s):   05/23/2018, 09/26/2016
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
36480915
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Application Form109/26/2016View
22Fee Calculator Form109/26/2016View
33Cover Letter from Applicant409/26/2016View
44Application Form (Signed)109/26/2016View
55Zoning Self-Certification209/26/2016View
66Sanborn Plat109/26/2016View
77Zoning Map109/26/2016View
88Surveyor's Plat509/26/2016View
99Letter of Authorization109/26/2016View
1010Certificate of Proficiency109/26/2016View
1111Statement of Applicant1509/26/2016View
1212List of Names and Mailing Addresses of Property Owners within 200 Feet2209/26/2016View
1313A1Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 1)709/26/2016View
1413A2Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 2)609/26/2016View
1514Statement of Intended Use 109/26/2016View
1615Color Photographs109/26/2016View
1716Copy of Filing Fee Check109/30/2016View
1817Letter in Opposition from Jeffrey Lin103/13/2018View
1917BZA Referral to ANC 5E110/05/2016View
2018BZA Referral to SMDANC 5E01110/05/2016View
2119BZA Referral to OP110/05/2016View
2220BZA Referral to DDOT110/05/2016View
2321BZA Referral to City Councilmember, Ward Five110/05/2016View
2422BZA Referral to City Councilmember, At-Large- Elissa Silverman110/05/2016View
2523BZA Referral to City Councilmember, At-Large - David Grosso110/05/2016View
2624BZA Referral to City Councilmember, At-Large - Anita Bonds110/05/2016View
2725BZA Referral to City Councilmember, At-Large - Robert White, Jr.110/05/2016View
2826BZA Referral to Chairman of the Council - ( Phil Mendelson)110/05/2016View
2927BZA Notice of Public Hearing to ANC 5E210/07/2016View
3028BZA Notice of Public Hearing to Applicant - ( Jeff C. Utz, Goulston & Storrs)210/07/2016View
3129BZA Notice of Public Hearing to Property Owners within 200 feet.410/07/2016View
3230BZA Notice of Public Hearing to City Councilmember, Ward Five210/07/2016View
3331BZA Attestation110/07/2016View
3432Comments from Stephanie A. Robinson210/20/2016View
3533Returned PHNs610/24/2016View
3634Returned PHNs510/26/2016View
3735Returned PHN410/31/2016View
3836Returned PHN411/07/2016View
3937Comments from Colleen Williams Vyas111/08/2016View
4038Returned PHNs511/08/2016View
4139Request for Party Status from St. Paul's College Neighbors for Thoughtful Development511/22/2016View
4240Applicant's Request for Postponement311/29/2016View
4341Advanced Party Status Request Consideration101/10/2017View
4442Returned PHN401/10/2017View
4543Administrative Postponement101/23/2017View
4644Applicant's Second Request for Postponement302/01/2017View
4745Witness Cards102/08/2017View
4846Affidavit of Service102/14/2017View
4947Testimony of Kristin Taddei, Casey Trees605/09/2017View
5048Testimony of Rae Tamblyn105/09/2017View
5149Testimony of Helen Schietinger205/16/2017View
5250Testimony for Delores Bushong105/16/2017View
5351ANC 5E Report305/19/2017View
5452Applicant's Third Request for Postponement305/19/2017View
5553Corrected ANC 5E Report405/24/2017View
5654Applicant's Fourth Request for Postponement309/07/2017View
5755BZA Memo Regarding Postponement Request109/18/2017View
5856Letter from John Anderson Agreeing to Extension of Hearing109/27/2017View
5957Witness Cards109/27/2017View
6058Letter in Support from Bishop John Ricard, SSJ. Ph.D202/05/2018View
6159Letter in Support from Patricia McGuire, Trinity Washington University102/08/2018View
6260Letter in Support from Rev. Thomas G. Couglin, OMI202/09/2018View
6361Letter in Support from John Garvey, The Catholic University of America202/27/2018View
6462Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing CTR & Resumes302/28/2018View
6562ACover Letter from Applicant: Tab A (CTR)5902/28/2018View
6662BCover Letter from Applicant: Tab B (Resumes)302/28/2018View
6763Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing Prehearing Statement402/28/2018View
6864Applicant's Prehearing Statement2602/28/2018View
6964A1Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 1)302/28/2018View
7064A2Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 2)102/28/2018View
7164A3Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 3)202/28/2018View
7264A4Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 4)302/28/2018View
7364A5Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 5)302/28/2018View
7464A6Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 6)302/28/2018View
7564A7Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 7)602/28/2018View
7664A8Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 8)602/28/2018View
7764A9Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 9)502/28/2018View
7864A10Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 10)602/28/2018View
7964A11Applicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans - Part 11)1002/28/2018View
8064BApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab B (Evolution of the Plan)102/28/2018View
8164CApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab C (Surveyor's Plat)102/28/2018View
8264DApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab D (Updated Application and Self-Cert Forms)302/28/2018View
8364EApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab E (Updated Plat and Zoning Map)202/28/2018View
8464FApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab F (Outlines of Witness Testimony)702/28/2018View
8564GApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab G (Expert Witness Resumes)702/28/2018View
8664HApplicant's Prehearing Statement: Tab H (Enlargement of Tree Plan Inventory)102/28/2018View
8765Form 150 Motion to Reschedule Hearing103/02/2018View
8866Letter from David Brown Requesting to Postpone Hearing303/02/2018View
8967Letter in Support from Cynthia M. A. Morris103/05/2018View
9069Letter in Opposition from Stephanie Robinson303/06/2018View
9170Affidavit of Posting503/06/2018View
9271Applicant's Response to Request for Postponement of Hearing403/09/2018View
9372OP Report103/09/2018View
9473DDOT Report603/09/2018View
9574Letter in Opposition from Peter Poon303/10/2018View
9675Letter in Opposition from Marcos DaCruz203/10/2018View
9776Letter in Opposition from Jennifer Renner303/12/2018View
9877Letter in Opposition from Sarah Kim203/12/2018View
9978Letter in Opposition from Kelly Boyer103/12/2018View
10079BZA Memo Granting Postponement to April 25, 2018103/13/2018View
10179Letter in Opposition from James DiLoreto203/13/2018View
10280Letter in Opposition from Natalie Vassall203/13/2018View
10381Letter in Opposition from Jeffrey Lin103/13/2018View
10482Letter in Opposition from Morgan Kennedy & Tobias Loss-Eaton303/19/2018View
10583Letter in Opposition from Brian & Adriana Wrenn203/27/2018View
10684Letter in Opposition from Jane Farrington & Shel Abramson103/30/2018View
10785Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing Supplemental Pre-Hearing504/04/2018View
10885AApplicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab A (Paulist Zoning Data)204/04/2018View
10985BApplicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Paulist Plans)404/04/2018View
11085C1Applicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab C (Townhouse Elevations - Part 1)604/04/2018View
11185C2Applicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab C (Townhouse Elevations - Part 2)504/04/2018View
11285DApplicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab D (GAR Sample Scoresheet)104/04/2018View
11385EApplicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement: Tab E (A&T Lots)104/04/2018View
11486Affidavit of Posting504/09/2018View
11587Referral to DCPR104/10/2018View
11688Referral to DME104/10/2018View
11789OP Report1404/13/2018View
11890Letter in Opposition from Michael Frohm104/17/2018View
11991Comments in Opposition from Alexandra Salomon104/17/2018View
12092Letter in Opposition from Mai-Trang D. Dang104/17/2018View
12193Letter in Opposition from Susan B. McCusker204/19/2018View
12294Affidavit of Maintenance404/19/2018View
12395Comments from Colleen Williams Vyas104/20/2018View
12496Technical Correction to its 3/9/2018 Report104/20/2018View
12597Letter in Support from Kristin Taddei, Casey Trees704/20/2018View
12698Comments from Amit Vyas104/20/2018View
12799Letter in Opposition from Jacob Ritting504/20/2018View
128100Letter in Support from Charter School Incubator Initiative204/20/2018View
129101Letter in Opposition from Timothy & Kristen Powell204/23/2018View
130102Comments from Chancellor's Row Homeowners' Association604/23/2018View
131102AComments from Chancellor's Row Homeowners' Association: Tab A (Updated Zoning Map)104/23/2018View
132102BComments from Chancellor's Row Homeowners' Association: Tab B (Site Plan)104/23/2018View
133103Comments from Vincenza Kamwendo104/23/2018View
134104Comments in Opposition from Sam Freund204/23/2018View
135105Letter in Support from Ann Howard, SNDdeN104/23/2018View
136106Comments from Jennifer Jones204/24/2018View
137107Comments from Bess Fox104/24/2018View
138108Letter in Opposition from Justin Melnikoff104/24/2018View
139109Letter in Support from Rev. Michael J. Kelley, Pastor104/24/2018View
140110Testimony of Edward Garnett604/24/2018View
141110APowerPoint Presentation304/24/2018View
142110BCorrection to ANC Testimony104/27/2018View
143111Comments in Opposition from Adrienne Johnson104/24/2018View
144111Comments in Opposition from Adrienne Johnson104/24/2018View
145112Letter in Opposition from Julius Ritting (Age 7)104/24/2018View
146113Letter in Opposition from Faye Hammersley504/24/2018View
147114Comments in Opposition from Helen LaCroix304/24/2018View
148115Comments in Opposition from Stephanie Bishop104/24/2018View
149116Letter in Opposition from Frances Walters604/24/2018View
150117Comments in Opposition from Megan Thynge104/24/2018View
151118Comments in Opposition from Carrie Seltzer104/24/2018View
152119Letter in Opposition from Byron Lutz204/24/2018View
153120Comments from Heidi Glenn104/24/2018View
154121Letter in Opposition from Michael Brown104/24/2018View
155122Comments in Opposition from Sophie Bethune204/24/2018View
156123Letter in Opposition from Patrick Farley204/24/2018View
157124Letter from David Brown Informing the Board He Would Not Attend the Public Hearing for Tomorrow (4/25/18)204/24/2018View
158125Comments in Opposition from Sam Gilford104/24/2018View
159126Comments in Opposition from Jane Crumpler204/25/2018View
160127Applicant's PowerPoint Presentation6404/25/2018View
161128Letter in Opposition from David Burns204/25/2018View
162129Comments in Opposition from Tracy Caswell w/Attachments304/25/2018View
163129ALetter in Opposition: Tab A (Washington Post Article)304/25/2018View
164129BLetter in Opposition: Tab B (Scientific Study)1404/25/2018View
165129CLetter in Opposition: Tab C (Future Land Use Map)104/25/2018View
166130Comments from Shawn and Susann Edwards204/25/2018View
167131Comments in Opposition from Katie Wendel104/25/2018View
168132Comments in Opposition from Ryan Crumpler104/25/2018View
169133Comments in Opposition from Claudia Salazar and Miguel Porrua104/25/2018View
170134Comments in Opposition from Anthony R. Picarello, Jr. Esq.304/25/2018View
171135Comments from Michael Jones and Leslie D.W. Jones204/25/2018View
172136Testimony from Barbara Deutsch, FASLA604/25/2018View
173136APowerPoint Presentation from Barbara Deutsch, FASLA2504/25/2018View
174137Comments from Sarah Doss Holby104/25/2018View
175138Draft Agreement Submitted by Applicant704/25/2018View
176139Testimony of Bryan Martin Firvida204/25/2018View
177140Color Photographs Submitted by Kirsten Olean504/25/2018View
178141Testimony in Opposition from Tracey Caswell2604/25/2018View
179142Witness Cards304/25/2018View
180143Letter in Opposition from Jennifer Concino405/02/2018View
181144Letter in Opposition from Peter Poon405/02/2018View
182144Letter in Opposition from Marcos DaCruz705/02/2018View
183145Letter in Opposition from Heather Sacks305/03/2018View
184146Comments from Colleen Williams Vyas205/04/2018View
185147Comments from Stephanie Holloway105/07/2018View
186148Comments from Dio Favatas105/07/2018View
187149Comments from Natalie Vassall105/07/2018View
188150Letter in Opposition from Brady Renner (Age 5)105/07/2018View
189151Comments from Kristen Riley305/07/2018View
190152Comments from Amit Vyas205/07/2018View
191153Testimony of Jennifer Renner905/07/2018View
192153AArticle Letter in Support of Opposition from Jennifer Renner505/09/2018View
193154Comments from Jordan Tenenbaum505/07/2018View
194155Comments in Opposition from Stephanie Holloway205/07/2018View
195156Comments in Opposition from Mai-Trang Dang205/07/2018View
196157Letter in Opposition from Catharina Vandervoort205/08/2018View
197158Comments in Opposition from Byron Caswell205/08/2018View
198159Amended Letter in Opposition from Faye Hammersley305/08/2018View
199160Letter in Opposition from Lisa DeRoo & Andreas Villaveces205/08/2018View
200161Letter in Opposition from Donna Hatley, PhD305/08/2018View
201162Letter in Opposition from Jennifer Suzara205/08/2018View
202163Letter in Opposition from Claudia Salazar and Miguel Porrua305/08/2018View
203164Additional Comments in Opposition from Marcos DaCruz27005/08/2018View
204165Letter in Opposition from Lisa DeRoo & Andres Villaveces205/08/2018View
205166Additional Comments Jane Farrington405/09/2018View
206167Written Testimony from Kirsten Olean605/09/2018View
207168Letters in Opposition from Joerge Dreweke105/09/2018View
208169Letter in Opposition from Jennifer and Erik Mitchell305/09/2018View
209170Post-Hearing Submission705/09/2018View
210170APost-Hearing Submission: Tab A (Ownership Maps)505/09/2018View
211170B1Post-Hearing Submission: Tab B (Updated Plans - Part 1)605/09/2018View
212170B2Post-Hearing Submission: Tab B (Updated Plans - Part 2)605/09/2018View
213170B3Post-Hearing Submission: Tab B (Updated Plans - Part 3)905/09/2018View
214170CPost-Hearing Submission: Tab C (Form Open Space and Roadway Public Use Easement)1205/09/2018View
215170DPost-Hearing Submission: Tab D (Tree Preservation Plan)105/09/2018View
216171A1Opposition from LMPCS Kids (Part 1)905/09/2018View
217171A2Opposition from LMPCS Kids (Part 2)805/09/2018View
218172Article from Scientific American "U.S. Cities Lose Tree Cover Just When They Need It Most" from Jennifer Renner605/09/2018View
219173Comments in Opposition from Jennifer and Erick Mitchell305/09/2018View
220174Letter in Opposition from Christina Borja205/09/2018View
221175Letter in Opposition from Tracy Caswell205/09/2018View
222176Letter in Opposition from Stephanie J. Bishop105/09/2018View
223177Comments in Opposition from Rachel Tardiff205/09/2018View
224178Letter in Opposition from Allison Denny205/10/2018View
225179OP Supplemental Report205/16/2018View
226180Second Letter of General Comments from Chancellor's Row Homeowners Association405/16/2018View
227180ASecond Letter of General Comments: Tab A (Site Plan)105/16/2018View
228180BSecond Letter of General Comments: Tab B (Site Plan)105/16/2018View
229181A1Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 1)505/17/2018View
230181A2Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 2)205/17/2018View
231181A4Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 3)105/17/2018View
232181A4Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 4)105/17/2018View
233181A5Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 5)105/17/2018View
234181A6Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 6)105/17/2018View
235181A7Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 7)105/17/2018View
236181A8Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 8)105/17/2018View
237181A9Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 9)105/17/2018View
238181A10Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 10)105/17/2018View
239181A11Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 11)105/17/2018View
240181A12Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 12)105/17/2018View
241181A13Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 13)105/17/2018View
242181A14Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 14)105/17/2018View
243181A15Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 15)105/17/2018View
244181A16Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 16)105/17/2018View
245181A17Response from John Anderson to Applicant's May 9, 2018 Submission w/Photographs (Part 17)105/17/2018View
246182Supplemental Report from DDOT405/18/2018View
247183Cover Letter Enclosing Letter of Commitments205/23/2018View
248183ALetter of Commitment905/23/2018View
249185Applicant PowerPoint Presentation1305/23/2018View
250186Comments in Opposition from Anthony R. Picarello, Jr., Esq.305/23/2018View
251187Additional Comments in Opposition from Anthony R. Picarello, Jr., Esq.305/23/2018View
252188Final Landscape Plan1205/24/2018View
253189Final IZ Unit Location Plan105/24/2018View
254190USCCB Fence Exhibit105/24/2018View
255191Witness Cards305/23/2018View
256192Applicant's Post-Hearing Statement606/28/2018View
257192APost-Hearing Statement: Tab A (Draft Order)2106/28/2018View
258192B1Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 1)1306/28/2018View
259192B2Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 2)1506/28/2018View
260192B3Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 3)2206/28/2018View
261192B4Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 4)306/28/2018View
262192B5Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 5)806/28/2018View
263192B6Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 6)906/28/2018View
264192B7Post-Hearing Statement: Tab B (Plans - Pt. 7)906/28/2018View
265192CPost-Hearing Statement: Tab C (Proposed IZ Locations)106/28/2018View
266193Comments in Opposition from USCCB Office of General Counsel306/29/2018View
267193AComments in Opposition from USCCB Office of General Counsel (5/23/2018)306/29/2018View
268193BComments in Opposition from USCCB Office of General Counsel (4/25/2018)306/29/2018View
269194Response from St. Paul's College Neighbors for Thoughtful Development207/10/2018View
270195Decision and Order1610/24/2019View
271196Attestation210/24/2019View
Orders
OrdersAction
Decision and OrderView
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
07/11/2018Public MeetingView
05/23/2018Public HearingView
04/25/2018Public HearingView
09/27/2017Public HearingView
05/31/2017Public HearingView
02/22/2017Public HearingView
02/08/2017Public HearingView
01/11/2017Public HearingView
12/07/2016Public HearingView
Videos
Related Videos
We could not found any videos. Click here to search for past hearings by using DCOZ Video On Demand tool.
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
5E
HUMA IMTIAZ
Visit Website
SMD
5E01
KYLE GARDINER
Visit Website