Exhibits

row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit #Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11 1Application Form11/19/2021View
22 2Appellant's Statement in Support321/19/2021View
33 3Letter of Authorization11/19/2021View
44 4November 19, 2020 Subdivision of Lot 108 Square 19211/19/2021View
55 5Certificate of Service11/19/2021View
66 6Expert Report of Professor James McCrery with CV241/19/2021View
77 7Expert Report of Architect Ravi Ricker with CV81/19/2021View
88A8A1HPRB Presentation Package with Drawings Prepared by Architects for Property Owner (Part 1)301/19/2021View
98A8A2HPRB Presentation Package with Drawings Prepared by Architects for Property Owner (Part 2)301/19/2021View
108A8A3HPRB Presentation Package with Drawings Prepared by Architects for Property Owner (Part 3)301/19/2021View
119 9November 19, 2020 Subdivision of Lot 108 Square 19211/19/2021View
1210 10Draft Zoning Determination Letter (September 2018 - written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to sign)41/19/2021View
1311 11Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant dated September 25, 2018 - 1733 16th St NW to Ferris 10-30-1821/19/2021View
1412 12Memorandum from Matt LeGrant, Zoning Administrator-DCRA41/19/2021View
1513 13BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2B72/11/2021View
1614 14BZA Referral/PHN to ANCSMD 2B0472/11/2021View
1715 15BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2F (Adjacent) 72/11/2021View
1816 16BZA Referral to OANC12/11/2021View
1917 17BZA Referral to OP12/11/2021View
2018 18BZA Referral/PHN to DCRA62/11/2021View
2119 19BZA Referral/PHN to Council of the District of Columbia, Ward 232/11/2021View
2220 20BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Christina Henderson)12/11/2021View
2321 21BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Anita Bonds)12/11/2021View
2422 22BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Robert White, Jr.)12/11/2021View
2523 23BZA Referral to Chairman of the Council (Phil Mendelson)12/11/2021View
2624 24BZA PHN to Property Owner62/11/2021View
2725 25BZA PHN to Appellant (Edward Hanlon)62/11/2021View
2826 26Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule803/11/2021View
2927 27DCRA's Opposition to Appellant's Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule403/17/2021View
3028 28Reply of Appellants DECAA and Michael D. Hays to DCRA’s Opposition to Motion to Revise Submission Schedule53/28/2021View
3129 29DECAA's Supplemental Statement in Support of Appeal54/21/2021View
3229A29A(1) 1911 - Application for Permit to Build - Permit No. 152714/21/2021View
3329B29B(2) 1911 - Building Permit No. 152714/21/2021View
3429C29C(3) A Guidebook to the House of the Temple (published by the Masons in 2015)84/21/2021View
3529D29D(4) Closeup Photo of Masonic Temple Pyramidal Roof14/21/2021View
3629E29E(5) From the Masons' website Masons Laying the Cornerstone and the Pyramidal Roof14/21/2021View
3729F29F(6) Screenshot from the Masons' website - John Russell Pope and the Stepped Pyramidal Roof14/21/2021View
3829G29G(7) Aerial Photo of 16th St14/21/2021View
3930 30ANC 2B Report154/26/2021View
4031 31BZA Memo - Hearing Administratively Rescheduled to July 28, 2021 through Webex104/29/2021View
4132 32Corrected Notice of Public Hearing704/29/2021View
4233 33Revised Referral/PHN to ANC 2B04705/03/2021View
4334 34DCRA's Opposed Motion to Consolidate and for Leave to File its Responsive Brief by July 21, 2021405/06/2021View
4435 35Appellants' Response to DCRA's Motion to Consolidate45/10/2021View
4536 36Appellants' Opposition to DCRA Resquest to Set July 21 2021 for Its Response and Appellants' Motion to Set Revised Schedule85/10/2021View
4637 37BZA Memo setting Filing Deadlines105/21/2021View
4738 38Cover Letter Enclosing Prehearing Statement37/2/2021View
4839 39Perseus' Prehearing Statement207/2/2021View
4939A39APrehearing Statement: Tab A (1919 Baist Map of Former Lot 800)17/2/2021View
5039B39BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Building Height Measurement Elevations)37/2/2021View
5139C39CPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab C (Zoning Diagram)107/02/2021View
5239D39DPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab D (Appendix of Prior BZA Decisions)3007/02/2021View
5339E39EPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab E (Appendix of Prior Zoning Administrator Determination Ltrs.)2107/02/2021View
5439F39FPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab F (Act of June 1, 1910 ch. 263 36 Stat 452 (Original Height Act)407/02/2021View
5539G39GPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab G (Temple Building Permit No. 1527 and Permit Application)307/02/2021View
5639H39HPerseus' Prehearing Statement: Tab H (Examples of Architectural Embellishments Functioning as a Roof)1407/02/2021View
5740 40Motion to Exclude DECCA's Proffered Expert Ravi Ricker307/02/2021View
5841 41Perseus/Developer Letter of Authorization107/02/2021View
5942 42DCRA's Prehearing Statement1407/02/2021View
6042A42ADCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Subdivision)107/02/2021View
6142B42BDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab B (West Elevation 16th St.)107/02/2021View
6242C42CDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab C (Subdivision Site Plan)107/02/2021View
6342D42DDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab D (Matt L. Ltr and Selected Slides)2707/02/2021View
6442E42EDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab E (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
6542F42FDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab F (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
6643 43DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Bar the Testimony of Ravi Ricker307/02/2021View
6744 44DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of Michael D. Hays307/02/2021View
6845 45Opposition to DCRA Motion In Limine to Exclude Testimony of Michael D. Hays87/9/2021View
6946 46DECAA's Opposition to DCRA’s Motion In Limine to Bar Licensed Architect Ravi Ricker from Testifying67/9/2021View
7047 47DECAA's Opposition to Perseus’ Motion to Exclude Architect Ravi Ricker from Testifying67/9/2021View
7148 48Reply Statement from Michael Hays457/19/2021View
7249 49Reply Statement from Professor James McCrery277/19/2021View
7350 50Supplement to J. McCrery Expert Report87/19/2021View
7451 51Photo of the Font Steps of the Temple17/19/2021View
7552 52Three Photos of 11.5 ft High Stone Structure in the Middle of the New Rear Yard37/19/2021View
7653 53Google Earth Screenshot of 'Rear Yard Showing Part of Front Steps and 11.5 Wall Will be in New Year Yard17/19/2021View
7754 54FOIA Request to DCRA -- 2021-FOIA-0191847/19/2021View
7855 55FOIA Request to DCRA -- 2021-FOIA-0191947/19/2021View
7956 56DCRA FOIA Officer's Acknowledgement of Receipt of 2021-FOIA-0191817/19/2021View
8057 57February 9, 2021 Email from DCRA attaching DCRA's Response to 2021-FOIA-01918 and 2021-FOIA-0191917/19/2021View
8158 58DCRA's FINAL RESPONSE to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 and 2021-FOIA-0191937/19/2021View
8259 59Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Requests 2021-FOIA-01918 and 2021-FOIA-0191917/19/2021View
8360 60Architectural Review January 191627/19/2021View
8461 61Photo of the Temple from the Front Showing the 11.5 ft. High Structure from the Front 17/19/2021View
8562 62DECAA's Reply to Pre-Hearing Statements of DCRA and Perseus97/19/2021View
8663 63Certificate of Service37/20/2021View
8764 64Appellants' Joint Motion in Limine to Bar Expert Testimony Alternatively Motion to Postpone and Compel Disclosure97/25/2021View
8865 65Written Testimony of Francisca Cromwell207/26/2021View
8966 66Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation177/26/2021View
9067 67DCRA's PowerPoint Presentation1107/27/2021View
9168 68Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation717/27/2021View
9269 69DCRA's Consent Motion to Continue Hearing407/28/2021View
9370 70List of Witnesses-July 28,2021107/29/2021View
9471 71BZA Memo - Granting Consent Motion to Postpone Hearing to November 10, 2021108/02/2021View
9572 72May 9, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant Transmitting Letter with Zoning Questions19/18/2021View
9673 73May 9, 2019 Letter from Hanlon to LeGrant with Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
9774 74May 31, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant (3rd request) Asking for a Response to Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
9875 75LeGrant's June 27, 2021 Reply to Hanlon's May 9 and May 31 Emails39/18/2021View
9976 76Law Suit Filed by DCRA's FOIA Officer 2018 CA 005787 Genet v. District of Columbia Government et. al529/18/2021View
10077 77Form 150 Joint Motion DECCA and Michael D. Hays19/18/2021View
10177A77AJoint Motion of Appellants to Supplement Statement of Issues to Include Claim the Subdivision Violates 11-B DCMR § 324.1(a)259/18/2021View
10278 78DCRA's Opposition to Appellants Joint Motion to Amend Issues on Appeal 1409/27/2021View
10379 79Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Motion to Amend Appeal to Add New Claim69/27/2021View
10480 80Reply of DECAA and Michael D. Hays to the Oppositions to Appellants' Motion to Supplement119/30/2021View
10581 81Form 150 Motion for Summary Reversal - DECAA110/6/2021View
10682 82Joint Motion of DECAA and Michael D. Hays For Summary Reversal710/6/2021View
10783 83Perseus and Property Owners' Joint Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Summary Reversal510/13/2021View
10883A83AJoint Opposition to Motion for Summary Reversal: Tab A (Plans Reviewed by ZA and Sent to Appellants Via Email)1110/13/2021View
10984 84Joint Reply of Appellants to Opposition to Motion For Summary Reversal510/18/2021View
11085 85Supplemental Expert Report of Prof. James McCrery Regarding Violation of Section 324.1(a)1210/19/2021View
11185A85AZoning Code Review Submitted by Architect Ravi Ricker210/19/2021View
11286 86Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
11387 87Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation10210/20/2021View
11487A87AAppellants' Slide 102 (Study of Carriage House)3910/20/2021View
11587B87BAppellants' Slide 5 (IZIS Ex 11-Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018)210/20/2021View
11687C87CAppellants' Slide 6 (IZIS Ex 10-Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign)410/20/2021View
11787D87DAppellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 12-Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018)410/20/2021View
11887E87EAppellants' Slide 8 (Screenshot DCRA Website Page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zoning Determination Letters)110/20/2021View
11987F87FAppellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 54-FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918)410/20/2021View
12087G87GAppellants' Slide 10 (Attachment to FOIA Request)110/20/2021View
12187H87HAppellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 58-DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)310/20/2021View
12287I87IAppellants' Slide 12 (IZIS Ex 59-Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919)110/20/2021View
12387J87JAppellants' Slide 13 (Curriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery)1210/20/2021View
12488 88Certificate of Service310/20/2021View
12589A89A11. Photo of Mr. Hanlon Standing on the Granite Bench Next to the Wall Taken from the Front of Temple110/20/2021View
12689A89A22. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from the Front110/20/2021View
12789A89A33. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from Alley110/20/2021View
12889A89A44. Close-up of the Wall Showing it is Made of Solid Granite110/20/2021View
12989A89A55. Photo Looking Down the Alley Towards 16th Street110/20/2021View
13089A89A66 Photo Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along Subdivision Line110/20/2021View
13189A89A77. Photo Showing 6 Feet from Property Line in the Rear110/20/2021View
13289A89A88. Measuring the Width Access Aisle110/20/2021View
13389A89A99. Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along the Subdivision Line)110/20/2021View
13490 90Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
13591 91Request to Accept Untimely Filing or Reopen the Record310/26/2021View
13692 92Intervenor Request from Wendy Schumacher1110/26/2021View
13792A92AIntervenor Request - Photo of Blocked Vehicles110/26/2021View
13892B92BIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Column110/26/2021View
13992C92CIntervenor Request - Photo of Window & Alley110/26/2021View
14092D92DIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Tree110/26/2021View
14192E92EIntervenor Request - Photo of Overhead View110/26/2021View
14293 93Certificate of Service110/26/2021View
14394 94Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Request to Intervene411/2/2021View
14495 95DCRA's Praecipe Joining Perseus TDC LLC's Opposition to Request to Intervene311/03/2021View
14596 96Perseus' Prehearing Statement311/3/2021View
14696A96APrehearing Statement: Tab A (Resume of Jeff Lockwood)111/3/2021View
14796B96BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Zoning Diagram)111/3/2021View
14897 97Appellants' Powerpoint Presentation11611/7/2021View
14998 98Appellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 11) - Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018211/7/2021View
15099 99Appellants' Slide 8 (IZIS Ex 10) - Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign411/7/2021View
151100 100Appellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 12) - Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018411/7/2021View
152101 101Appellants' Slide 10 - Screenshot DCRA Website Page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zon Det Letters111/7/2021View
153102 102Appellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 54) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918411/7/2021View
154103 103Appellants' Slide 12 - Attachment to FOIA Request111/7/2021View
155104 104Appellants' Slide 13 (IZIS Ex. 55) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01919 Filed by Edward Hanlon in December 2020411/7/2021View
156105 105Appellants' Slide 15 (IZIS Ex 58)DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)311/7/2021View
157106 106Appellants' Slide 16 (IZIS Ex 59) - Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919111/7/2021View
158107 107Appellants' Slide 17 - Cirriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery1211/7/2021View
159108 108Appellants' Slide 111 - Study of Carriage House-Compressed3911/7/2021View
160109 109BZA - Appellant's Slide 114- Resume of Architect Ravi Ricker211/7/2021View
161110 110BZA - Certificate of Service - Appellants' Slides 11-7-21)211/7/2021View
162111 111Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation1711/8/2021View
163112 112Appellants' Consent Motion To Continue the Hearing311/9/2021View
164113 113Comments from Alan Gambrell211/10/2021View
165114 114BZA Memo - Postponed to Hearing February 23, 2022111/12/2021View
166115 115Emergency Motion to Stay Construction and Request for Expedited Hearing (Form 150)112/7/2021View
167116 116Emergency Motion to Stay Construction and Request for Expedited Hearing Date2212/7/2021View
168117 117Declaration of Nicholas DelleDonne612/7/2021View
169118 118Affidavit of Wendy Schumacher312/7/2021View
170119 119Opposition to Motion for Stay of Construction and to Expedite Hearing1112/14/2021View
171119A119AOpposition to Motion: Tab A (Prior Orders Denying Stay of Project Approvals)1512/14/2021View
172120 120BZA Memo - Board to Consider Motions to Stay, Expedite Hearing at Public Mtg December 22, 2021112/17/2021View
173121 121Reply to the Opposition of DCRA and Perseus TDC to DECAA’s Emergency Motion to Stay Construction612/17/2021View
174122 122Appellants' Joint Motion To Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery as an Expert222/1/2022View
175123 123Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation62/2/2022View
176124 124Certificate of Service22/2/2022View
177125 125Architectural Drawings Previously Submitted by the Masonic Temple to DCRA132/2/2022View
178126 126Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Joint Motion for Expert Qualification42/8/2022View
179127 127DCRA's Praecipe Joining Perseus' Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Expert Qualification302/09/2022View
180128 128Appellants' Reply to Opp to Motion to Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery72/11/2022View
181129 129DCRA PowerPoint Presentation62/20/2022View
182130 130Notice of DC Court of Appeals Decision & Ex. A72/21/2022View
183131 131Appellants' Opening PowerPoint Presentation - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #133132/21/2022View
184132 132Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation272/22/2022View
185133 133Appellants’ Amended Opening Power Point Presentation142/22/2022View
186134 134List of Witnesses-February 23, 2022102/23/2022View
187135 135Request to Reopen the Record from Edward Hanlon, Esq.112/01/2022View