Exhibits

row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit #Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11 1Application Form11/18/2021View
22 2DC Surveyor's Plat11/15/2021View
33 3Certificate of Service11/17/2021View
44 4Organizational or ANC Report11/18/2021View
55 5Expert Report of Professor J. McCrery with CV261/18/2021View
66 6Statement of Appeal461/18/2021View
77 7BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2B72/10/2021View
88 8BZA Referral/PHN to ANCSMD 2B0572/10/2021View
99 9BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2F (Adjacent)72/10/2021View
1010 10BZA Referral to OANC12/10/2021View
1111 11BZA Referral to OP12/10/2021View
1212 12BZA Referral/PHN to DCRA62/10/2021View
1313 13BZA Referral/PHN to Council of the District of Columbia, Ward 232/10/2021View
1414 14BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Christina Henderson)12/10/2021View
1515 15BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Anita Bonds)12/10/2021View
1616 16BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Robert White, Jr.)12/10/2021View
1717 17BZA Referral to Chairman of the Council (Phil Mendelson)12/10/2021View
1818 18BZA PHN to Property Owner62/10/2021View
1919 19BZA PHN to Appellent (Michael Hayes)62/10/2021View
2020 20Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule803/11/2021View
2121 21DCRA's Opposition to Appellant's Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule403/17/2021View
2222 22Reply of Appellants DECAA and Michael D. Hays to DCRA’s Opposition to Motion to Revise Submission Schedule53/28/2021View
2323 23Supplement to Statement of Appellant Michael D. Hays104/21/2021View
2423A23ASupplement to Expert Report of James Curtis McCrery II, Architect804/21/2021View
2523B23BCertificate of Service104/21/2021View
2624 24ANC 2B Report154/26/2021View
2725 25BZA Memo - Hearing Administratively Rescheduled to July 28, 2021 through Webex104/29/2021View
2826 26Corrected Notice of Public Hearing704/29/2021View
2927 27Revised Referral/PHN to ANC 2B04705/03/2021View
3028 28DCRA's Motion to Consolidate and for Leave to File its Responsive Brief by July 21, 2021405/06/2021View
3129 29Appellants' Response to DCRA's Motion to Consolidate45/10/2021View
3230 30Appellants' Opposition to DCRA Resquest to Set July 21 2021 for Its Response and Appellants' Motion to Set Revised Schedule85/10/2021View
3331 31BZA Memo setting Filing Deadlines105/21/2021View
3432 32Cover Letter Enclosing Prehearing Statement37/2/2021View
3533 33Perseus' Prehearing Statement207/2/2021View
3633A33APrehearing Statement: Tab A (1919 Baist Map of Former Lot 800)17/2/2021View
3733B33BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Building Height Measurement Elevations)37/2/2021View
3833C33CPrehearing Statement: Tab C (Zoning Diagram)17/2/2021View
3933D33DPrehearing Statement: Tab D (Appendix of Prior BZA Decisions)307/2/2021View
4033E33EPrehearing Statement: Tab E (Appendix of Prior Zoning Administrator Determination Letters)217/2/2021View
4133F33FPrehearing Statement: Tab F (Act of June 1, 1910 ch. 263, 36 Stat. 452 (Original Height Act)47/2/2021View
4233G33GPrehearing Statement: Tab G (Temple Building Permit No. 1527 and Permit Application)37/2/2021View
4333H33HPrehearing Statement: Tab H (Examples of Architectural Embellishments Functioning as a Roof)147/2/2021View
4434 34Motion to Exclude Appellant DECAA's Proferred Expert Ravi Ricker37/2/2021View
4535 35Letter of Authorization from Developer/Perseus17/2/2021View
4636 36DCRA's Prehearing Statement1407/02/2021View
4736A36ADCRA's Prehearing: Tab A (Subdivision)107/02/2021View
4836B36BDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab B (West Elevation 16th St.)107/02/2021View
4936C36CDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab C (Subdivision Site Plan)107/02/2021View
5036D36DDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab D (Matt L. Ltr and Selected Slides)2707/02/2021View
5136E36EDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab E (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
5236F36FDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab F (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
5337 37DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Bar the Testimony of Ravi Ricker307/02/2021View
5438 38DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of Michael D. Hays307/02/2021View
5539 39Opposition to DCRA Motion In Limine to Exclude Testimony of Michael D. Hays87/9/2021View
5640 40Reply Statement from Michael Hays457/19/2021View
5741 41Reply Statement from Professor James McCrery277/19/2021View
5842 42Appellants' Joint Motion in Limine to Bar Expert Testimony Alternatively Motion to Postpone and Compel Disclosure97/26/2021View
5943 43Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation177/26/2021View
6044 44DCRA's PowerPoint Presentation1107/27/2021View
6145 45Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation717/27/2021View
6246 46DCRA's Consent Motion to Continue Hearing407/28/2021View
6347 47List of Witnesses-July 28, 2021107/29/2021View
6448 48BZA Memo - Granting Consent Motion to Postpone Hearing to November 10, 2021108/02/2021View
6549 49May 9, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant Transmitting Letter with Zoning Questions19/18/2021View
6650 50May 9, 2019 Letter from Hanlon to LeGrant with Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
6751 51May 31, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant (3rd request) Asking for a Response to Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
6852 52LeGrant's June 27, 2021 Reply to Hanlon's May 9 and May 31 Emails39/18/2021View
6953 53Law Suit Filed by DCRA's FOIA Officer 2018 CA 005787 Genet v. District of Columbia Government et. al529/18/2021View
7054 54Joint Motion of Appellants to Supplement Statement of Issues to Include Claim the Subdivision Violates 11-B DCMR § 324.1(a)259/18/2021View
7155 55DCRA's Opposition to Appellant's Joint Motion to Amend the Issues on Appeal1409/27/2021View
7256 56Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Motion to Amend Appeal to Add New Claim69/27/2021View
7357 57Reply of DECAA and Michael D. Hays to the Oppositions to Appellants' Motion to Supplement119/30/2021View
7458 58Form 150 Motion for Summary Reversal - Hays110/6/2021View
7559 59Joint Motion of DECAA and Michael D. Hays For Summary Reversal710/6/2021View
7660 60Perseus and Property Owners' Joint Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Summary Reversal510/13/2021View
7760A60AJoint Opposition to Motion for Summary Reversal: Tab A (Plans Reviewed by ZA and Sent to Appellants Via Email)1110/13/2021View
7861 61Joint Reply of Appellants to Opposition to Motion For Summary Reversal510/18/2021View
7962 62Supplemental Expert Report of Prof. James McCrery Regarding Violation of Section 324.1(a) 1210/19/2021View
8062A62AZoning Code Review Submitted by Architect Ravi Ricker210/20/2021View
8163 63Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
8264 64Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation10210/20/2021View
8364A64AAppellants' Slide 102 (Study of Carriage House)3910/20/2021View
8464B64BAppellants' Slide 5 (IZIS Ex 11-Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018)210/20/2021View
8564C64CAppellants' Slide 6 (IZIS Ex 10-Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign)410/20/2021View
8664D64DAppellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 12-Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018)410/20/2021View
8764E64EAppellants' Slide 8 (Screenshot DCRA website page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zoning Determination Letters)110/20/2021View
8864F64FAppellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 54-FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918)410/20/2021View
8964G64GAppellants' Slide 10 (Attachment to FOIA Request)110/20/2021View
9064H64HAppellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 58-DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)310/20/2021View
9164I64IAppellants' Slide 12 (IZIS Ex 59-Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919)110/20/2021View
9264J64JAppellants' Slide 13 (Curriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery)1210/20/2021View
9365 65Certificate of Service310/20/2021View
9466A66A11. Photo of Mr. Hanlon Standing on the Granite Bench Next to the Wall Taken from the Front of Temple110/20/2021View
9566A66A22. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from the Front110/20/2021View
9666A66A33. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from Alley110/20/2021View
9766A66A44. Close-up of the Wall Showing it is Made of Solid Granite110/20/2021View
9866A66A55. Photo Looking Down the Alley Towards 16th Street110/20/2021View
9966A66A66 Photo Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along Subdivision Line110/20/2021View
10066A66A77. Photo Showing 6 Feet from Property Line in the Rear110/20/2021View
10166A66A88. Measuring the Width Access Aisle110/20/2021View
10266A66A99. Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along the Subdivision Line110/20/2021View
10367 67Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
10468 68Request to Accept Untimely Filing or Reopen the Record310/26/2021View
10569 69Intervenor Request from Wendy Schumacher1110/26/2021View
10669A69AIntervenor Request - Photo of Blocked Vehicles110/26/2021View
10769B69BIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Column110/26/2021View
10869C69CIntervenor Request - Photo of Window & Alley Below110/26/2021View
10969D69DIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Tree110/26/2021View
11069E69EIntervenor Request - Photo of Overhead View110/26/2021View
11170 70Certificate of Service110/27/2021View
11271 71Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Request to Intervene411/2/2021View
11372 72DCRA's Praecipe Joining Perseus TDC LLC's Opposition to Request to Intervene311/03/2021View
11473 73Perseus' Prehearing Statement311/3/2021View
11573A73APrehearing Statement: Tab A (Resume of Jeff Lockwood)111/3/2021View
11673B73BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Zoning Diagram)111/3/2021View
11774 74Appellants' Powerpoint Presentation11611/7/2021View
11875 75Appellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 11) - Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018211/7/2021View
11976 76Appellants' Slide 8 (IZIS Ex 10) - Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign411/7/2021View
12077 77Appellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 12) - Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018411/7/2021View
12178 78Appellants' Slide 10 - Screenshot DCRA Website Page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zon Det Letters111/7/2021View
12279 79Appellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 54) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918411/7/2021View
12380 80Appellants' Slide 12 - Attachment to FOIA Request111/7/2021View
12481 81Appellants' Slide 13 (IZIS Ex. 55) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01919 Filed by Edward Hanlon in December 2020411/7/2021View
12582 82Appellants' Slide 15 (IZIS Ex 58) - DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)311/7/2021View
12683 83Appellants' Slide 16 (IZIS Ex 59) - Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919111/7/2021View
12784 84Appellants' Slide 17 - Cirriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery1211/7/2021View
12885 85Appellants' Slide 111 - Study of Carriage House-Compressed3911/7/2021View
12986 86BZA - Appellant's Slide 114- Resume of Architect Ravi Ricker211/7/2021View
13087 87BZA - Certificate of Service - Appellants' Slides 11-7-21)211/7/2021View
13188 88Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation1711/8/2021View
13289 89Comments in Support from Alan Gambrell211/09/2021View
13390 90Appellants' Consent Motion To Continue the Hearing311/9/2021View
13491 91BZA Memo - Postponed to Hearing February 23, 2022111/12/2021View
13592 92Appellants' Joint Motion To Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery as an Expert222/1/2022View
13693 93Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation62/2/2022View
13794 94Certificate of Service22/2/2022View
13895 95Architectural Drawings Previously Submitted by the Masonic Temple to DCRA132/2/2022View
13996 96Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Joint Motion for Expert Qualification42/8/2022View
14097 97DCRA's Praecipe Joining Persus' Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Expert Qualification302/09/2022View
14198 98Appellants' Reply to Opp to Motion to Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery72/11/2022View
14299 99PowerPoint Presentation from DCRA62/20/2022View
143100 100Notice of DC Court of Appeals Decision & Ex. A72/21/2022View
144101 101Appellants' Opening PowerPoint Presentation - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #103132/21/2022View
145102 102Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation272/22/2022View
146103 103Appellants’ Amended Opening Power Point Presentation142/22/2022View
147104 104List of Witnesses-February 23, 2022102/23/2022View