Case 20944

Case Overview
Application of:   Advisory Neighborhood Commission 3D and Rohit Kumar (Case Withdrawn)
Case Summary:   Appeal from decisions made by the Department of Buildings to issue building permits to allow a detached principal dwelling in the R-1B zone.
Appeal from decisions made by the Department of Buildings to issue building permits to allow a detached principal dwelling in the R-1B zone.
Address:   5122 Cathedral Avenue, N.W. (Square 1439, Lot 60)
ANC:   3D04
Relief:  
TypeReliefPursuant To
AppealN/ASubtitle X § 1100
Case Type:   Appeal
Case Status:   Closed
Past Hearing Date(s):   07/02/2025, 03/05/2025, 12/18/2024, 09/18/2024, 06/12/2024, 03/13/2024, 02/07/2024, 11/15/2023, 10/04/2023
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
143960
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Application Form14/28/2023View
22Amended Statement of Appeal84/30/2023View
32AStatement: Tab A (Building Permit No 2303238)24/28/2023View
42BStatement: Tab B (ZA -010)24/28/2023View
52CStatement: Tab C (Site Plan)14/28/2023View
62DStatement: Tab D (Existing Plans - Sheet D101)14/28/2023View
72EStatement: Tab E (Letter from ANC 3D to ZA re 5122 Cathedral Avenue NW - Notice)544/28/2023View
82FStatement: Tab F (DOB 5122 Cathedral Presentation)124/28/2023View
92GStatement: Tab G (Neighbor Reconsideration Request for 5122 Cathedral Ave NW)384/28/2023View
102HStatement: Tab H (OZA Letter - 5122 Cathedral Ave NW - Signed Final)64/28/2023View
113Letter of Authorization14/30/2023View
124Certificate of Service14/30/2023View
135Addendum to Form 125 - Contact Information for Rohit Kumar14/30/2023View
146Letter of Authorization (ANC 3D)14/28/2023View
157Letter from ANC 3D64/28/2023View
168Statement of Appeal - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #274/28/2023View
179Certificate of Service14/28/2023View
1810Receipt.pdf15/15/2023View
1911BZA Notice of Virtual Public Hearing 45/16/2023View
2012BZA Attestation/PHN List of Referrals 15/16/2023View
2113BZA Attestation/PHN List of Referrals17/28/2023View
2214Updated Witness List19/26/2023View
2315Motion to Dismiss from DOB39/27/2023View
2416ANC 3D Statement1509/27/2023View
2517Statement of Rohit Kumar49/29/2023View
2617A1Rohit Kumar Statement - Exhibits Part 1119/29/2023View
2717A2Rohit Kumar Statement - Exhibits Part 2139/29/2023View
2818Appellants' Response in Opposition to Appellee's Motion to Dismiss - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #1969/29/2023View
2919Appellants' Amended Response in Opposition to Appellee's Motion to Dismiss610/2/2023View
3020Testimony of Tricia Duncan, ANC 3D610/3/2023View
3120AANC 3D PowerPoint Presentation810/03/2023View
3221Permit Cancellation - 5122 Cathedral Ave NW210/4/2023View
3322List of Witnesses-October 4, 2023110/04/2023View
3423BZA Memo - Rescheduled Hearing to November 15, 2023110/04/2023View
3524ANC 3D Report110/16/2023View
3625DOB Supplemental Filing411/8/2023View
3725AAttachments to DOB Supplemental Filing1011/8/2023View
3826List of Witnesses-November 15, 2023111/15/2023View
392720944 - BZA Memo Rescheduling Hearing to February 7, 2024102/01/2024View
4028Second Motion to Dismiss from DOB32/5/2024View
4129DOB Motion to Dismiss Exhibit #1 (Building Permit B2310998)12/5/2024View
4230Appellant's Opposition to Second Motion to Dismiss72/6/2024View
4330APages from Architectural Plans 502/06/2024View
4431ANC 3D PowerPoint Presentation92/6/2024View
4532ANC 3D Testimony42/6/2024View
4633Property Owner's PowerPoint Presentation1002/06/2024View
4733ACertificate of Service102/06/2024View
4834Appellant's Motion to Reopen the Record and Exclude Exhibit #33402/06/2024View
4935List of Witnesses-February 7, 2024102/07/2024View
5036Postponed to Hearing on March 13, 2024102/10/2024View
5137Appellant's Second Amended Statement of Appeal52/15/2024View
5238ANC 3D and RK Memo of Objections to 1.31.24 Plans52/15/2024View
5338AExhibits for ANC3D and RK Objections to 1.31.24 Plans172/15/2024View
5439DOB's Notice to Revoke B231099823/8/2024View
5540Third Motion to Dismiss From DOB, or in the Alternative, Continue33/8/2024View
5641Appellant's Opposition to Third Motion to Dismiss63/11/2024View
5742Appellant's Motion to Continue43/12/2024View
5843List of Witnesses-March 13, 2024103/14/2024View
5944BZA Memo - Continued to Hearing on June 12, 2024103/14/2024View
6045Appellants' Supplemental Statement35/21/2024View
6146Motion to Dismiss from DOB46/4/2024View
6246AMotion: Tab A (Surrender of Permit)46/4/2024View
6347Appellants' Motion to Continue56/7/2024View
6448Appellants' Opposition to Appellee's Fourth Motion to Dismiss66/7/2024View
6549Appellant's PowerPoint Presentation1106/10/2024View
6650A1Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 1) - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #57A1906/10/2024View
6750A2Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBITS #57A2 & #57A3706/10/2024View
6851Certificate of Service106/10/2024View
6952Statement from Tricia Duncan, ANC 3D16/11/2024View
7053Email from Kathleen Beeton, DOB to Commissioner Tricia Duncan, ANC/SMD 3D02306/12/2024View
7154Email from Kathleen Beeton, DOB to Mr. Agarwal306/12/2024View
7255List of Witnesses-June 12, 2024106/14/2024View
7356BZA Memo - Postponed to Hearing on September 18, 2024; DOB Motion to Dismiss Denied106/20/2024View
7457A1Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 1)3208/14/2024View
7557A2Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 2)2508/14/2024View
7657A3Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations (Part 3)608/14/2024View
7757BProperty Owner's Update on the DOB Process208/14/2024View
7857CProof of Service108/14/2024View
7958Motion to Dismiss Appeal as Moot Submitted by Karan Keith Agarwal (Property Owner)308/23/2024View
8059Appellants' Opposition to Permit Applicant's Motion to Dismiss48/27/2024View
8160DOB's Fifth Motion to Dismiss49/11/2024View
8261List of Witnesses-September 18, 2024109/18/2024View
8362BZA Memo - Postponed to December 18, 2024109/19/2024View
8463DOB's Request for a Postponement - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #65412/11/2024View
8564Appellant's Consent to Postponement212/12/2024View
8664AAppellant's Supplemental Consent to Postponement312/16/2024View
8765Amended DOB's Motion for Postponement412/16/2024View
8866List of Witnesses-December 18, 2024112/19/2024View
8967BZA Memo-Postponed to Hearing on March 5, 2025112/19/2024View
9068DOB's Status Report 22/26/2025View
9169Appellant's Motion to Postpone Decision Hearing of March 5, 2025203/03/2025View
9270BZA Memo-Postponed to Hearing on July 2, 2025103/05/2025View
9371List of Witnesses-March 5, 2025403/06/2025View
9472Motion to Dismiss - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #7315/14/2025View
9572AAppellants' Motion to Dismiss - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #7325/14/2025View
9673Letter from Tracy Themak Requesting to Withdraw Appeal105/22/2025View
9774Letter from BZA Acknowledging Withdrawal of Appeal105/22/2025View
Orders
No Order(s) found
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
03/05/2025Public HearingView
12/18/2024Public HearingView
09/18/2024Public HearingView
06/12/2024Public HearingView
03/13/2024Public HearingView
02/07/2024Public HearingView
11/15/2023Public HearingView
10/04/2023Public HearingView
10/04/2023Public HearingView
Videos
Related VideosAction
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 10/04/2023View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 11/15/2023View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 02/07/2024View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 03/13/2024View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 06/12/2024View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 10/04/2023View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 09/18/2024View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 12/18/2024View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 03/05/2025View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 10/04/2023View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 02/07/2024View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 03/13/2024View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 06/12/2024View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 09/18/2024View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 12/18/2024View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 03/05/2025View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 11/15/2023View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 07/02/2025View
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
3D
BERNIE HORN
Visit Website
SMD
3D04
MARK M. BLUMENTHAL
Visit Website