Zoning Case Search

Case Overview

Application of:

Penguin, LLC

Case Summary:

To construct a detached, two-story with basement principal dwelling unit in the R-1-A zone.

Address:

4509 FOXHALL CRESCENT NW (Square 1397, Lot 960)

ANC:

SMD3D01

Relief:

Type	Relief	Pursuant To
Special Exception	The subdivision regulations of Subtitle C § 302.1	Subtitle C § 305.1 and Subtitle X § 901.2
Area Variance	The vehicular ingress and egress requirements of Subtitle C § 305.3(b)	Subtitle X § 1002

Case Type:

Special Exception,Variance

Case Status:

Closed

Result:

Approved 4 - 0 - 1

Past Hearing Date(s):

06/15/2022, 05/18/2022, 05/18/2022, 03/02/2022

Past Meeting Date(s):

06/29/2022

Property Information:

Square	Lot(s)
1397	0960

Project Image

Map Inset

Exhibits

row_num#	Exhibit #	Exhibit Description	Number of Pages	Exhibit Date	Action
1	1	Application Form	1	11/1/2021	View
2	2	DC Surveyor's Plat	1	11/1/2021	View
3	3	Statement of Existing and Intended Use	1	11/1/2021	View
4	4	Zoning Self-Certification - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #13	2	11/1/2021	View
5	5	Color Photographs	16	11/1/2021	View
6	6	Architectural Plans and Elevations	8	11/1/2021	View
7	7	List of Names and Mailing Addresses of Property Owners within 200 Ft	1	11/1/2021	View
8	8	Applicant's Statement	11	11/1/2021	View
9	9	Letter of Authorization	1	11/1/2021	View
10	10	Certification of Proficiency	1	11/1/2021	View
11	11	Statement of Community Outreach	1	11/1/2021	View
12	12	Certificate of Service	1	11/1/2021	View
13	13	Updated Zoning Self-Certification - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #27A	2	11/1/2021	View
14	14	Receipt	1	11/8/2021	View
15	15	BZA Notice of Virtual Public Hearing	4	11/12/2021	View
16	16	BZA Referrals	1	11/12/2021	View
17	17	Attestation	1	01/27/2022	View
18	18	Proof of Publication of PHN to DC Register	1	01/28/2022	View
19	19	Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing Postponement Request	2	2/8/2022	View
20	19A	Applicant's Request for Postponement	1	2/8/2022	View
21	20	Corrected BZA Referrals	1	01/27/2022	View
22	21	Request for Party Status from Andrew Wong	6	02/14/2022	View
23	21A1	Request for Party Status from Andrew Wong (Part 1)	21	02/14/2022	View
24	21A2	Request for Party Status from Andrew Wong (Part 2)	9	02/14/2022	View
25	22	Request for Party Status from John D. Fox	3	02/16/2022	View
26	22A	Proof of Service of Party Request from John Fox	1	02/18/2022	View
27	22B	Proof of Service to ANC 3D of Party Status Request from John Fox	1	02/18/2022	View
28	23	DDOT Report	2	02/18/2022	View
29	24	BZA Memo - Granting Postponement to Hearing May 18, 2022	1	02/18/2022	View
30	25	Letter from Sullivan & Barros Withdrawing Representation	2	03/02/2022	View
31	26	Letter of Authorization for Saul Ewing Arnstein & Lehr	3	4/7/2022	View
32	27	Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing Updated Zoning Self-Certification	1	4/26/2022	View
33	27A	Updated Zoning Self-Certification - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #54G	2	4/26/2022	View
34	28	Cover Letter from Applicant	3	4/28/2022	View
35	28A1	Cover Letter: Tab A (Updated Architectural Plans - Part 1)	3	4/28/2022	View
36	28A2	Cover Letter: Tab A (Updated Architectural Plans - Part 2)	5	4/28/2022	View
37	28A3	Cover Letter: Tab A (Updated Architectural Plans - Part 3)	5	4/28/2022	View
38	28B-E	Cover Letter: Tab B-E	15	4/28/2022	View
39	29	OP Report	9	5/5/2022	View
40	30	Motion to Accept Untimely Filing from Jody Westby (Form 153)	1	04/27/2022	View
41	31	Certificate of Service from J Westby	1	04/27/2022	View
42	32	Request for Party Status in Support from Jody Westby, FCHA	7	04/27/2022	View
43	33	Written Testimony from Michael Carter, DPW	3	05/09/2022	View
44	34	Applicant's Request for Postponement	3	5/9/2022	View
45	35	Objection to Applicant's Motion for Postponement	1	05/13/2022	View
46	35A	Objection to Applicant's Motion for Postponement	2	05/13/2022	View
47	36	Applicant's Response to Objection of Postponement Request	2	05/16/2022	View
48	37	Letter in Support of Postponement Request from Foxhill Crescents Home Owner Association	1	5/16/2022	View
49	38	Applicant's 2nd Response to Objection of Postponement Request	2	5/16/2022	View
50	39	ANC 3D Report	5	5/17/2022	View
51	40	BZA Memo - Party Status Consideration on May 25, 2022; Hearing Postponed to June 15, 2022	1	05/18/2022	View
52	41	Letter of Authorization (Foxhall Crescents Homeowners Association)	1	05/19/2022	View
53	42	Applicant's Motion to Deny Party Status Request from John Fox	5	5/20/2022	View
54	43	Letter from Robert & Phoebe Sharkey in Support of Party Status Request from John Fox	1	05/23/2022	View
55	44	Letter from Gene & Patricia Godley in Support of Party Status Request from John Fox	2	05/23/2022	View
56	45	Request to Accept an Untimely Filing (Form 153)from John Fox	1	05/23/2022	View
57	46	2nd Request for Party Status (Representation)	3	05/24/2022	View
58	46A	Certificate of Service	1	05/24/2022	View
59	47	Letter from Pamela Kilian Fox in Support of Party Status Request from John Fox	1	05/24/2022	View
60	48	Applicant's Motion to Deny Party Status Request from John Fox	3	5/24/2022	View
61	49	Corrected 2nd Request for Party Status (Representative)	1	05/24/2022	View
62	49A	Corrected Certificate of Service-John Fox	1	05/24/2022	View
63	50	Applicant's Motion to Deny 2nd Party Status Request from John Fox	3	05/24/2022	View
64	51	Motion to Accept Late Filing & Certificate of Service	2	05/25/2022	View
65	51A	Motion to Submit Response to Party Status from Applicant	3	05/25/2022	View
66	52	List of Witnesses-May 25, 2022	1	05/25/2022	View
67	53	BZA Memo - Granting Party Status in Support to Jody Westby for Foxhall Crescents HOA	1	05/25/2022	View
68	54	Applicant's Supplemental Statement	2	5/27/2022	View
69	54A	Supplemental Statement: Tab A (Updated Conditions and Site Plans)	5	5/27/2022	View
70	54B	Supplemental Statement: Tab B (Updated Elevations)	2	5/27/2022	View
71	54C	Supplemental Statement: Tab C (Updated Landscape & Tree Plans)	4	5/27/2022	View
72	54D	Supplemental Statement: Tab D (Stormwater Management Plan)	4	5/27/2022	View
73	54E	Supplemental Statement: Tab E (Sediment and Soil Erosion Plan)	2	5/27/2022	View
74	54F	Supplemental Statement: Tab F (Statement of Compliance)	17	5/27/2022	View
75	54G	Supplemental Statement: Tab G (Updated Zoning Self-Certification) - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #69B	3	5/27/2022	View
76	55	Cover Letter from FCHOA Enclosing Letter in Support	2	5/27/2022	View
77	55A	Letter in Support from FCHOA	35	5/27/2022	View
78	56	Request for Late Filing to Submit Party Status Request from Gene & Patricia Godley and Phoebe & Robert Sharkey	2	6/1/2022	View
79	57	Request for Party Status in Opposition from Gene & Patricia Godley	7	6/1/2022	View
80	57A	Godley Exhibits 1-2 (Color Photographs)	6	6/1/2022	View
81	57B	Godley Exhibits 3-4 (Color Photographs & Summary Order No. 18708)	14	6/1/2022	View
82	57C	Godley Exhibit 5 (Agreement for Development of Rockefeller Estate)	11	6/1/2022	View
83	57D1	BZA Godley Exhibit 6 (Office of Administrator for Planning & Development Report) Part 1	10	6/1/2022	View
84	57D2	BZA Godley Exhibit 6 (Office of Administrator for Planning & Development Report) Part 2	6	6/1/2022	View
85	57E	BZA Godley Exhibits 7-9 (Ltr. from Thomas Shannon, Maps & Multiple Building Covenant)	15	6/1/2022	View
86	58	Request for Party Status in Opposition from Phoebe & Robert Sharkey	6	6/1/2022	View
87	58A	BZA Sharkey Exhibit 1 (Bautista Letter)	3	6/1/2022	View
88	58B	BZA Sharkey Ex. 2 (DC Large Tract Review Report)	15	6/1/2022	View
89	59	Affidavit of Posting	4	6/8/2022	View
90	60	Letter in Support of Party Status Requests from Gene & Patricia Godley and Phoebe & Robert Sharkey from Chuck Elkins, Commissioner ANC 3D01	1	06/09/2022	View
91	60A	Certificate of Service	1	06/09/2022	View
92	61	OP Supplemental Report	11	6/9/2022	View
93	62	Applicant's Letter Re: Deny Party Status Request	3	6/9/2022	View
94	63	Letter of Opposition to Request for Party Status from FCHOA	4	6/9/2022	View
95	64	Distance Map screenshot	1	6/9/2022	View
96	66	Foxhall Crescents Resident Distance Map	1	6/9/2022	View
97	68	Copy of BZA Order No. 15882	9	6/9/2022	View
98	69	Applicant's Supplemental Statement	3	6/10/2022	View
99	69A	Supplemental Statement: Tab A (Updated Site Plan)	1	6/10/2022	View
100	69B	Supplemental Statement: Tab B (Updated Zoning Self-Certification, Elevations and Site Plans	4	6/10/2022	View
101	70	THERE IS NO DOCUMENT FOR THIS EXHIBIT	2	6/13/2022	View
102	71	THERE IS NO DOCUMENT FOR THIS EXHIBIT	6	6/13/2022	View
103	72	THERE IS NO DOCUMENT FOR THIS EXHIBIT	45	6/13/2022	View
104	73A1	Applicant's Letter Re: Concerns with ANC 3D (Part 1)	4	6/13/2022	View
105	73A2	Applicant's Letter Re: Concerns with ANC 3D (Part 2)	4	6/13/2022	View
106	74	Applicant's Letter Re: Slope Stability Study	34	6/13/2022	View
107	75	Opposition's PowerPoint Presentation	18	06/14/2022	View
108	76	Applicant's Request for Civil Engineer Substitution	3	6/14/2022	View
109	77	FCHOA Request to Substitute Expert Witness w/Photos	1	6/14/2022	View
110	77A	Color Photograph #1	1	6/14/2022	View
111	77B	Color Photograph #2	1	6/14/2022	View
112	77C	Color Photograph #3	1	6/14/2022	View
113	77D	Color Photograph #4	1	6/14/2022	View
114	77E	Color Photograph #5	1	6/14/2022	View
115	77F	Color Photograph #6	1	6/14/2022	View
116	77G	Color Photograph #7	1	6/14/2022	View
117	77H	Color Photograph #8	1	6/14/2022	View
118	77I	Color Photograph #9	1	6/14/2022	View
119	77J	Color Photograph #10	1	6/14/2022	View
120	77K	Color Photograph #11	1	6/14/2022	View
121	77L	Color Photograph #12	1	6/14/2022	View
122	77M	Color Photograph #13	1	6/14/2022	View
123	77N	Color Photograph #14	1	6/14/2022	View
124	78	Certificate of Service	1	6/14/2022	View
125	79	Applicant's Presentation	2	06/15/2022	View
126	80	DOEE Review	4	06/15/2022	View
127	81	Foxhall Crescents Neighborhood Analysis	1	06/15/2022	View
128	82	BZA Memo - Denial of Party Status; Decision Meeting 6/29/22; Docs requested	2	06/16/2022	View
129	83	Cover Letter from Opposition Enclosing Testimony & Bylaws	2	06/17/2022	View
130	83A	Testimony from Gene & Patricia Godley and Robert & Phoebe Sharkey	6	06/17/2022	View
131	83B	FCHOA 1994 Bylaws	45	06/17/2022	View
132	84	Cover Letter from Applicant Enclosing Post-hearing Statement	2	06/21/2022	View
133	84A	Project Grading Plan	1	06/21/2022	View
134	84B	Gene Godley Deed of Sale	3	06/21/2022	View
135	84C	Property Deed	4	06/21/2022	View
136	84D	Construction Management Plan	3	06/21/2022	View
137	85A1	Testimony from Jody Westby (Part 1)	6	06/21/2022	View
138	85A2	Testimony from Jody Westby (Part 2)	7	06/21/2022	View
139	86	FCHOA's Response to Opposition's Testimony	4	6/27/2022	View
140	87	Applicant's Letter to Chairman Hill & BZA - Response to Opposition's Filing on 6/16/2022	13	6/27/2022	View
141	88	Decision and Order	13	02/26/2024	View
142	89	Attestation	1	02/26/2024	View

Orders

Orders	Action
Decision and Order	View

Transcripts

Transcript Date	Meeting Type	Action
06/29/2022	Public Meeting	View
05/25/2022	Public Hearing	View
05/18/2022	Public Hearing	View

Videos

Related Videos	Action
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 05/18/2022	View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 05/25/2022	View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Meeting on 06/29/2022	View
Hearing Hearing on 03/02/2022	View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 06/15/2022	View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 05/18/2022	View
Public Meeting Public Meeting on 06/29/2022	View

DC Office of Zoning

Office of Zoning
202-727-6311
[email protected]

Office of Planning

Office of Planning
202-442-7600
[email protected]

ANC

SMD

Case 20636