Case 20594

Case Overview
Application of:   Nezahat and Paul Harrison
Case Summary:   To raze an existing principal dwelling unit, and subdivide the lot to construct two new, detached, principal dwelling units in the R-8 zone.
To raze an existing principal dwelling unit, and subdivide the lot to construct two new, detached, principal dwelling units in the R-8 zone.
Address:   3007 Albemarle St NW (Square 2041, Lot 818)
ANC:   3F03
Relief:  
TypeReliefPursuant To
Special ExceptionThe theoretical lot subdivision requirements under Subtitle C § 305Subtitle X § 901.2
Area VarianceThe lot dimension requirements of Subtitle D § 502Subtitle X § 1002
Case Type:   Variance
Case Status:   Closed
Result:   Approved 4 - 0 - 1
Past Hearing Date(s):   07/20/2022, 05/18/2022, 04/13/2022, 12/22/2021
Past Meeting Date(s):   07/27/2022
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
20410818
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Application Form18/26/2021View
22Location Surveyor's Plat18/10/2021View
33Color Photographs78/10/2021View
44List of Names and Mailing Addresses of Property Owners within 200 Ft.28/10/2021View
55Memo from Matt LeGrant, Zoning Administrator-DCRA28/10/2021View
66Zoning Self-Certificate-1st Page - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #7718/10/2021View
77Architectural Plans and Elevations - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #1718/10/2021View
88DCFD Report18/10/2021View
99Correspondence Between Paul Harrison and Mary Eckstein28/10/2021View
1010Correspondence Between Paul Harrison and Naima Chambliss18/10/2021View
1111DC Surveyor's Plat18/10/2021View
1212Zoning Map Excerpt18/10/2021View
1313Statement of Public Outreach18/10/2021View
1414Extended Site Plan - Setback Variance18/11/2021View
1515Zoning Self-Certification-Page 2 - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #7718/11/2021View
1616Updated Statement of Existing and Intended Use18/11/2021View
1717Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #7598/26/2021View
1818Letter of Authorization19/3/2021View
1919Letter of Certification19/3/2021View
2020Compliance Letter from DCRA19/3/2021View
2121Form 120 Application19/3/2021View
2222Statement of the Applicant - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #76139/3/2021View
2323Receipt19/13/2021View
2424BZA Public Hearing Notice49/27/2021View
2525BZA PHN Attestation19/27/2021View
2626Applicant's Prehearing Statement512/1/2021View
2726A1Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Plans and Elevations)912/1/2021View
2826A2Prehearing Statement: Tab A (Civil and Landscape Plan)312/1/2021View
2926BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Ferreira Resume)412/1/2021View
3026CPrehearing Statement: Tab C (CAS-DC DCL Resume)212/1/2021View
3126DPrehearing Statement: Tab D (Outline of Witness Testimony)312/1/2021View
3227Request for Party Status in Opposition from Deborah Ann Hernandez412/2/2021View
3328Request for Party Status in Opposition from Mary Lee112/3/2021View
3428AAttachment to Party Status Request from Mary Lee w/Certifcate of Service412/3/2021View
3528BResume of Guillermo Rueda, AIA312/3/2021View
3628CDG Capability Statement112/3/2021View
3729Party Status Requester - Request for Postponement112/7/2021View
3830Request for Party Status in Opposition from John Baringer412/08/2021View
3931OP Report112/10/2021View
4032DDOT Report212/10/2021View
4133Letter in Opposition from Carol M. Schwab, Esq.112/13/2021View
4234Comments from Michela M. Perrone112/14/2021View
4335Letter in Support from Deborah Hernandez of the Request for Postponement112/17/2021View
4436Letter of Authorization112/17/2021View
4537Letter in Opposition from Caroline James112/20/2021View
4638Letter in Opposition from Charles W. Steller112/20/2021View
4739Letter in Opposition from Claudette Christian & Donald Hertzmark112/20/2021View
4840Letter in Opposition from Christine Schmidt112/20/2021View
4941Letter in Opposition from Susan Crudington & William McElwain112/20/2021View
5042Letter in Opposition from David Lockhart112/20/2021View
5143Letter in Opposition from Dorothy Fall112/20/2021View
5244Letter in Opposition from Joan McAvoy112/20/2021View
5345Letter in Opposition from Kathy Harllee112/20/2021View
5446Letter in Opposition from Nina Mason & Max Hirshfeld212/20/2021View
5547Letter in Opposition from Meghan Haigh112/20/2021View
5648Letter in Opposition from Michael & Stefanie Harrington112/20/2021View
5749Letter in Opposition from Paolo Mauro & Zuzana Murgasova112/20/2021View
5850Letter in Opposition from Marcia Pearcy112/21/2021View
5951Letter in Opposition from Laurel Christian112/21/2021View
6052Letter in Opposition from Douglas Rosenthal & Annemarie Hillman112/21/2021View
6153Letter in Opposition from Martin O'Hara, M.D.112/21/2021View
6254Letter in Opposition from Thorne Rankin112/22/2021View
6355Letter in Opposition from Eunice Montalvo112/22/2021View
6456Letter in Opposition from Sharon Langmaid112/22/2021View
6557BZA Memo - Granting Party Status; Postponed to Hearing April 13, 2022112/23/2021View
6658Letter in Opposition from Laura Albert112/27/2021View
6759Letter in Opposition from Judith & Joseph McManus112/27/2021View
6860Letter in Opposition from Scott F. Nolde112/28/2021View
6961Letter in Opposition from Rebecca & Gary Stevens112/28/2021View
7062Letter in Opposition from Ana Serra & Karl Driessen112/28/2021View
7163Letter in Opposition from Robert & Margaret Shanks112/28/2021View
7264Letter in Opposition from Trina Haque112/28/2021View
7365List of Witnesses-December 22, 2021112/30/2021View
7466Letter in Opposition from Edward Rippey101/04/2022View
7567Letter in Opposition from Kerstin Goebel & Werner Schuele101/04/2022View
7668Letter in Opposition from Margery Elfin101/04/2022View
7769Letter in Opposition from Saira Malik101/04/2022View
7870Letter in Opposition from Elizabeth Wallace201/04/2022View
7971Appleton Dedication and Subdivisions13/1/2022View
8072Revised Tree Planting Plan - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #8913/1/2022View
8173CIV200(Progress)13/1/2022View
8274TS Examples13/1/2022View
8375Updated Architectural Plans and Elevations93/1/2022View
8476Revised Burden of Proof223/1/2022View
8577Revised Zoning Self-Certification - SUPERSEDED, See Ex. 7823/1/2022View
8678Revised Zoning Self-Certification - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #8523/3/2022View
8779Attestation/PHN103/03/2022View
8880Letter of Authorization (Hernandez)13/4/2022View
8981Corrected BZA Attestation/PHN13/11/2022View
9082Motion for Request for Postponement from Mary Lee13/16/2022View
9183Request for Postponement from Mary Lee33/16/2022View
9284Letter from Deborah Hernandez Supporting Postponement23/17/2022View
9385Revised Zoning Self-Certification23/20/2022View
9486Applicant's Supplemental Pre-Hearing Statement33/23/2022View
9587Response to Party Opponent Motion for Continuance33/23/2022View
9688BZA Memo - Postponement granted to Hearing May 18, 2022103/29/2022View
9789Supplemental Revised Tree Plan23/30/2022View
9890Letter in Opposition from Margaret & Robert Shanks104/27/2022View
9991Letter in Opposition from Judith & Joseph McManus104/27/2022View
10092Letter in Opposition from Laurel Christian104/27/2022View
10193Letter in Opposition from Dorothy Fall104/27/2022View
10294Letter in Opposition from Nina Mason & Max Hirshfeld104/27/2022View
10395Letter in Opposition from Christine Schmidt104/27/2022View
10496Letter in Opposition from Stefanie & Michael Harrington104/27/2022View
10597Affidavit of Posting24/27/2022View
10698Letter in Opposition from Paolo Mauro & Zuzana Murgasova104/28/2022View
10799OP Report85/4/2022View
108100Letter of No Objection from Andrew Orlin105/05/2022View
109101Letter in Support from Marlene Berlin15/5/2022View
110102Baringer Cover Letter - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT # 10625/12/2022View
111103Baringer Letter of Authorization15/12/2022View
112104Certificate of Proficiency15/12/2022View
113105Baringer Statement in Opposition - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT # 10785/12/2022View
114106Baringer Cover Letter - Updated25/12/2022View
115107Baringer Statement in Opposition - Updated115/12/2022View
116108Letter in neither support nor opposition from S. F.105/13/2022View
117109Letter in Support from Rebecca & Justin Galen15/13/2022View
118110Applicant's Request for Postponement25/13/2022View
119111ANC 3F Report - Form 129205/12/2022View
120111ALetter from ANC 3F03 Commissioner605/12/2022View
121112Letter of Support for Postponement Request from John F. Baringer & Michela Perrone15/16/2022View
122113Letter of Support for Postponement Request from Deborah Ann Hernandez25/16/2022View
123114Letter in Support of Postponement Request from Mary Lee105/16/2022View
124115Letter in Support of Postponement Request from ANC 3F205/17/2022View
125116Letter in Opposition from Margery Elfin105/17/2022View
126117Letter in Opposition from Kathryn Harllee205/17/2022View
127118List of Witnesses-May 18, 2022105/19/2022View
128119BZA Memo - Postponed to Hearing July 20, 2022105/23/2022View
129120Letter of Support from Sharon Gaskin and Robert Butterfield 16/3/22View
130121Letter in Opposition from Jack Baringer & Michela Perrone36/5/2022View
131122Letter in Opposition from Caroline James106/07/2022View
132123Letter in Opposition from Laura Albert206/07/2022View
133124Letter in Opposition from Scott Nolde106/30/2022View
134125Second Affidavit of Posting37/6/2022View
135126Letter in Opposition from Wendy Hughes107/11/2022View
136127Letter in Opposition from Sharon Langmaid107/11/2022View
137128Second Letter in Opposition from Edward Rippey & Saira Malik107/11/2022View
138129Second Letter in Opposition from Charles Stellar & Neil Robinson107/12/2022View
139130Letter in Opposition from Anne Muscolino107/14/2022View
140131Motion to Include Additional Relief17/15/2022View
141132Opposition's Letter to Accept Guillermo Rueda as an Expert Witness617/15/2022View
142133John Baringer Letter Consenting to Opposition's Motion27/15/2022View
143134Affidavit of Maintenance17/17/2022View
144135Letter in Opposition from Neil Rodgers107/18/2022View
145136Mary Lee Letter Consenting to Opposition's Motion27/18/2022View
146137Pipestem Properties Forest Hills17/18/2022View
147138Properties in Forest Hill507/18/2022View
148139Certificate of Service107/18/2022View
1491402nd Letter in Opposition from Elizabeth Wallace207/18/2022View
150141Letter in Opposition from Thorne Rankin107/19/2022View
151142Letter in Opposition from Andrea & D. Andrew Austin107/19/2022View
152143Letter in Opposition from Sarah Margon107/19/2022View
153144Letter in Opposition from Martin O'Hara107/19/2022View
154145Letter in Opposition from Meredith Dresner107/19/2022View
155146Letter in Opposition from Daniel Heath107/19/2022View
156147PowerPoint Presentation from Mary Lee & Deb Hernandez807/19/2022View
157148Photos/Exhibits for Deb Hernandez Testimony907/19/2022View
1581492nd Letter in Opposition from Werner Schule107/19/2022View
1591502nd Letter in Opposition from Kerstin Gobel107/19/2022View
160151Applicant's PowerPoint Presentation257/19/2022View
161152Exhibits/Photos for Testimony from Deb Hernandez907/19/2022View
162153Request to Accept Untimely Filing from Paul Harrison27/19/2022View
163153ALetter in Opposition of Motion from Paul Harrison37/19/2022View
164154Letter in Support from Sam Buffone207/19/2022View
165155Testimony from Marlene Berlin107/19/2022View
166156Letter in Support from 2955 Albermarle St. NW107/19/2022View
167157Letter in Opposition from John Barringer to Applicant's Submission47/19/2022View
168158Letter in Support from David Cresteal, ANC 3F0127/20/2022View
169159Letter in Opposition from Doug Rosenthal107/20/2022View
170160Letter in Opposition from Kay Kornman107/20/2022View
171161Surveyor's Plat (March 11, 1975) Submitted by Deb Hernandez & Mary Lee)107/20/2022View
172162Lot 16 Water Mark View Survey Submitted by Deb Hernandez & Mary Lee107/20/2022View
1731633D Photographs from Deb Hernandez & Mary Lee207/20/2022View
1741641931 Baist Map Submitted by Applicant107/20/2022View
175165Albemarle Street Map Submitted by Deb Hernandez107/20/2022View
176166Written Testimony from Stan Wall, Commissioner, ANC 3F04307/20/2022View
177167BZA Memo - Decision Meeting July 27, 2022; Record closed except for Documents Requested107/21/2022View
178168List of Witnesses-July 20, 2022107/21/2022View
179169Closing Statement from Paul Harrison97/25/2022View
180170Closing Statement from Jack Baringer67/25/2022View
181171Testimony from Guillermo Rueda1007/26/2022View
182172Closing Statement from Deb Hernandez & Mary Lee807/26/2022View
183173Decision and Order110/23/2023View
184174Attestation110/23/2023View
Orders
OrdersAction
Decision and OrderView
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
10/18/2023Public HearingView
09/14/2022Public MeetingView
07/27/2022Public MeetingView
07/20/2022Public HearingView
05/18/2022Public HearingView
12/22/2021Public HearingView
Videos
Related VideosAction
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 12/22/2021View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 05/18/2022View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 07/20/2022View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Meeting on 07/27/2022View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Meeting on 09/14/2022View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 10/18/2023View
Meeting Meeting on 07/27/2022View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 05/18/2022View
Public Hearing Public Hearing on 07/20/2022View
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
3F
COURTNEY CARLSON
Visit Website
SMD
3F03
MITCHELL BAER
Visit Website