Case 20452

Case Overview
Application Of:   Michael Hays
Case Summary:   Appeal from the decision made on November 19, 2020 by the Zoning Administrator, Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs to approve the subdivision of Square 192, Lot 108 into two separate lots denoted as Lots 110 and 111 in the RA-8 and RA-9 Zones.
Address: 1733 16th Street, NW

Project: Appeal from the decision made on November 19, 2020 by the Zoning Administrator, Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs to approve the subdivision of Square 192, Lot 108 into two separate lots denoted as Lots 110 and 111 in the RA-8 and RA-9 Zones.

Relief: N/A

Pursuant to: Subtitle Y § 302
Address:   1733 16th Street, NW
ANC:   2B
Relief:   N/A
Pursuant To:   Subtitle Y § 302
Case Type:   Appeal
Case Status:   Active
Result:   Deny 5 - 0 - 0
Past Hearing Date(s):   02/23/2022, 11/10/2021, 07/28/2021, 07/28/2021, 05/12/2021
Past Meeting Date(s):   03/02/2022
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
Square 192108,110,111
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Application Form11/18/2021View
22DC Surveyor's Plat11/15/2021View
33Certificate of Service11/17/2021View
44Organizational or ANC Report11/18/2021View
55Expert Report of Professor J. McCrery with CV261/18/2021View
66Statement of Appeal461/18/2021View
77BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2B72/10/2021View
88BZA Referral/PHN to ANCSMD 2B0572/10/2021View
99BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 2F (Adjacent)72/10/2021View
1010BZA Referral to OANC12/10/2021View
1111BZA Referral to OP12/10/2021View
1212BZA Referral/PHN to DCRA62/10/2021View
1313BZA Referral/PHN to Council of the District of Columbia, Ward 232/10/2021View
1414BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Christina Henderson)12/10/2021View
1515BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Anita Bonds)12/10/2021View
1616BZA Referral to Council of the District of Columbia, At-Large (Robert White, Jr.)12/10/2021View
1717BZA Referral to Chairman of the Council (Phil Mendelson)12/10/2021View
1818BZA PHN to Property Owner62/10/2021View
1919BZA PHN to Appellent (Michael Hayes)62/10/2021View
2020Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule803/11/2021View
2121DCRA's Opposition to Appellant's Joint Motion to Revise Submission Schedule403/17/2021View
2222Reply of Appellants DECAA and Michael D. Hays to DCRA’s Opposition to Motion to Revise Submission Schedule53/28/2021View
2323Supplement to Statement of Appellant Michael D. Hays104/21/2021View
2423ASupplement to Expert Report of James Curtis McCrery II, Architect804/21/2021View
2523BCertificate of Service104/21/2021View
2624ANC 2B Report154/26/2021View
2725BZA Memo - Hearing Administratively Rescheduled to July 28, 2021 through Webex104/29/2021View
2826Corrected Notice of Public Hearing704/29/2021View
2927Revised Referral/PHN to ANC 2B04705/03/2021View
3028DCRA's Motion to Consolidate and for Leave to File its Responsive Brief by July 21, 2021405/06/2021View
3129Appellants' Response to DCRA's Motion to Consolidate45/10/2021View
3230Appellants' Opposition to DCRA Resquest to Set July 21 2021 for Its Response and Appellants' Motion to Set Revised Schedule85/10/2021View
3331BZA Memo setting Filing Deadlines105/21/2021View
3432Cover Letter Enclosing Prehearing Statement37/2/2021View
3533Perseus' Prehearing Statement207/2/2021View
3633APrehearing Statement: Tab A (1919 Baist Map of Former Lot 800)17/2/2021View
3733BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Building Height Measurement Elevations)37/2/2021View
3833CPrehearing Statement: Tab C (Zoning Diagram)17/2/2021View
3933DPrehearing Statement: Tab D (Appendix of Prior BZA Decisions)307/2/2021View
4033EPrehearing Statement: Tab E (Appendix of Prior Zoning Administrator Determination Letters)217/2/2021View
4133FPrehearing Statement: Tab F (Act of June 1, 1910 ch. 263, 36 Stat. 452 (Original Height Act)47/2/2021View
4233GPrehearing Statement: Tab G (Temple Building Permit No. 1527 and Permit Application)37/2/2021View
4333HPrehearing Statement: Tab H (Examples of Architectural Embellishments Functioning as a Roof)147/2/2021View
4434Motion to Exclude Appellant DECAA's Proferred Expert Ravi Ricker37/2/2021View
4535Letter of Authorization from Developer/Perseus17/2/2021View
4636DCRA's Prehearing Statement1407/02/2021View
4736ADCRA's Prehearing: Tab A (Subdivision)107/02/2021View
4836BDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab B (West Elevation 16th St.)107/02/2021View
4936CDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab C (Subdivision Site Plan)107/02/2021View
5036DDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab D (Matt L. Ltr and Selected Slides)2707/02/2021View
5136EDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab E (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
5236FDCRA's Prehearing Statement: Tab F (North Elevation)107/02/2021View
5337DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Bar the Testimony of Ravi Ricker307/02/2021View
5438DCRA's Partial Consent Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of Michael D. Hays307/02/2021View
5539Opposition to DCRA Motion In Limine to Exclude Testimony of Michael D. Hays87/9/2021View
5640Reply Statement from Michael Hays457/19/2021View
5741Reply Statement from Professor James McCrery277/19/2021View
5842Appellants' Joint Motion in Limine to Bar Expert Testimony Alternatively Motion to Postpone and Compel Disclosure97/26/2021View
5943Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation177/26/2021View
6044DCRA's PowerPoint Presentation1107/27/2021View
6145Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation717/27/2021View
6246DCRA's Consent Motion to Continue Hearing407/28/2021View
6347List of Witnesses-July 28, 2021107/29/2021View
6448BZA Memo - Granting Consent Motion to Postpone Hearing to November 10, 2021108/02/2021View
6549May 9, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant Transmitting Letter with Zoning Questions19/18/2021View
6650May 9, 2019 Letter from Hanlon to LeGrant with Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
6751May 31, 2019 Email from Hanlon to LeGrant (3rd request) Asking for a Response to Zoning Questions29/18/2021View
6852LeGrant's June 27, 2021 Reply to Hanlon's May 9 and May 31 Emails39/18/2021View
6953Law Suit Filed by DCRA's FOIA Officer 2018 CA 005787 Genet v. District of Columbia Government et. al529/18/2021View
7054Joint Motion of Appellants to Supplement Statement of Issues to Include Claim the Subdivision Violates 11-B DCMR § 324.1(a)259/18/2021View
7155DCRA's Opposition to Appellant's Joint Motion to Amend the Issues on Appeal1409/27/2021View
7256Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Motion to Amend Appeal to Add New Claim69/27/2021View
7357Reply of DECAA and Michael D. Hays to the Oppositions to Appellants' Motion to Supplement119/30/2021View
7458Form 150 Motion for Summary Reversal - Hays110/6/2021View
7559Joint Motion of DECAA and Michael D. Hays For Summary Reversal710/6/2021View
7660Perseus and Property Owners' Joint Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Summary Reversal510/13/2021View
7760AJoint Opposition to Motion for Summary Reversal: Tab A (Plans Reviewed by ZA and Sent to Appellants Via Email)1110/13/2021View
7861Joint Reply of Appellants to Opposition to Motion For Summary Reversal510/18/2021View
7962Supplemental Expert Report of Prof. James McCrery Regarding Violation of Section 324.1(a) 1210/19/2021View
8062AZoning Code Review Submitted by Architect Ravi Ricker210/20/2021View
8163Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
8264Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation10210/20/2021View
8364AAppellants' Slide 102 (Study of Carriage House)3910/20/2021View
8464BAppellants' Slide 5 (IZIS Ex 11-Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018)210/20/2021View
8564CAppellants' Slide 6 (IZIS Ex 10-Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign)410/20/2021View
8664DAppellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 12-Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018)410/20/2021View
8764EAppellants' Slide 8 (Screenshot DCRA website page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zoning Determination Letters)110/20/2021View
8864FAppellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 54-FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918)410/20/2021View
8964GAppellants' Slide 10 (Attachment to FOIA Request)110/20/2021View
9064HAppellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 58-DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)310/20/2021View
9164IAppellants' Slide 12 (IZIS Ex 59-Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919)110/20/2021View
9264JAppellants' Slide 13 (Curriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery)1210/20/2021View
9365Certificate of Service310/20/2021View
9466A11. Photo of Mr. Hanlon Standing on the Granite Bench Next to the Wall Taken from the Front of Temple110/20/2021View
9566A22. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from the Front110/20/2021View
9666A33. Photo of Column and Wall Taken from Alley110/20/2021View
9766A44. Close-up of the Wall Showing it is Made of Solid Granite110/20/2021View
9866A55. Photo Looking Down the Alley Towards 16th Street110/20/2021View
9966A66 Photo Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along Subdivision Line110/20/2021View
10066A77. Photo Showing 6 Feet from Property Line in the Rear110/20/2021View
10166A88. Measuring the Width Access Aisle110/20/2021View
10266A99. Showing Area in the Rear of the Temple with Fence Running Along the Subdivision Line110/20/2021View
10367Certificate of Service210/20/2021View
10468Request to Accept Untimely Filing or Reopen the Record310/26/2021View
10569Intervenor Request from Wendy Schumacher1110/26/2021View
10669AIntervenor Request - Photo of Blocked Vehicles110/26/2021View
10769BIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Column110/26/2021View
10869CIntervenor Request - Photo of Window & Alley Below110/26/2021View
10969DIntervenor Request - Photo of Wall & Tree110/26/2021View
11069EIntervenor Request - Photo of Overhead View110/26/2021View
11170Certificate of Service110/27/2021View
11271Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Request to Intervene411/2/2021View
11372DCRA's Praecipe Joining Perseus TDC LLC's Opposition to Request to Intervene311/03/2021View
11473Perseus' Prehearing Statement311/3/2021View
11573APrehearing Statement: Tab A (Resume of Jeff Lockwood)111/3/2021View
11673BPrehearing Statement: Tab B (Zoning Diagram)111/3/2021View
11774Appellants' Powerpoint Presentation11611/7/2021View
11875Appellants' Slide 7 (IZIS Ex 11) - Email from Attorney Ferris to ZA LeGrant Dated September 25 2018211/7/2021View
11976Appellants' Slide 8 (IZIS Ex 10) - Draft Zoning Determination Letter Sept 2018 Written by Atty Ferris for ZA LeGrant to Sign411/7/2021View
12077Appellants' Slide 9 (IZIS Ex 12) - Zoning Determination Letter Dated October 30 2018411/7/2021View
12178Appellants' Slide 10 - Screenshot DCRA Website Page Determination Letters Zoning Maps and Plans Purpose of Zon Det Letters111/7/2021View
12279Appellants' Slide 11 (IZIS Ex 54) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918411/7/2021View
12380Appellants' Slide 12 - Attachment to FOIA Request111/7/2021View
12481Appellants' Slide 13 (IZIS Ex. 55) - FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01919 Filed by Edward Hanlon in December 2020411/7/2021View
12582Appellants' Slide 15 (IZIS Ex 58) - DCRA's Final Response to FOIA Request 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919 (highlighted)311/7/2021View
12683Appellants' Slide 16 (IZIS Ex 59) - Only Document Supplied by DCRA in Response to FOIA Reqsts 2021-FOIA-01918 2021-FOIA-01919111/7/2021View
12784Appellants' Slide 17 - Cirriculum Vitae of Prof. James McCrery1211/7/2021View
12885Appellants' Slide 111 - Study of Carriage House-Compressed3911/7/2021View
12986BZA - Appellant's Slide 114- Resume of Architect Ravi Ricker211/7/2021View
13087BZA - Certificate of Service - Appellants' Slides 11-7-21)211/7/2021View
13188Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation1711/8/2021View
13289Comments in Support from Alan Gambrell211/09/2021View
13390Appellants' Consent Motion To Continue the Hearing311/9/2021View
13491BZA Memo - Postponed to Hearing February 23, 2022111/12/2021View
13592Appellants' Joint Motion To Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery as an Expert222/1/2022View
13693Appellants' PowerPoint Presentation62/2/2022View
13794Certificate of Service22/2/2022View
13895Architectural Drawings Previously Submitted by the Masonic Temple to DCRA132/2/2022View
13996Perseus' Brief in Opposition to Appellants' Joint Motion for Expert Qualification42/8/2022View
14097DCRA's Praecipe Joining Persus' Opposition to Appellants' Motion for Expert Qualification302/09/2022View
14198Appellants' Reply to Opp to Motion to Additionally Qualify Prof. James McCrery72/11/2022View
14299PowerPoint Presentation from DCRA62/20/2022View
143100Notice of DC Court of Appeals Decision & Ex. A72/21/2022View
144101Appellants' Opening PowerPoint Presentation - SUPERSEDED - SEE EXHIBIT #103132/21/2022View
145102Perseus' PowerPoint Presentation272/22/2022View
146103Appellants’ Amended Opening Power Point Presentation142/22/2022View
147104List of Witnesses-February 23, 2022102/23/2022View
Orders
No Order(s) found
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
03/02/2022Public MeetingView
02/23/2022Public HearingView
11/10/2021Public MeetingView
11/10/2021Public HearingView
07/28/2021Public HearingView
Videos
Related VideosAction
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 07/28/2021View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Meeting on 11/10/2021View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 11/10/2021View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Hearing on 02/23/2022View
Board of Zoning Adjustment Public Meeting on 03/02/2022View
Hearing Hearing on 02/23/2022View
Public Meeting Public Meeting on 03/02/2022View
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
2B
ZACHARY ADAMS
Visit Website
SMD