Zoning Case Search

Case Overview

Application of:

ANC 7D

Case Summary:

Appeal of ANC 7D, pursuant to 11 DCMR Subtitle Y § 302, from the determination made on October 16, 2018 by the Zoning Administrator, Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs, to allow a Fire Station as a matter-of-right use in the R-2 Zone at premises 4409 Minnesota Avenue N.E. (Square 5097, Lot 846).

Address:

4409 Minnesota Ave., NE, Washington, DC

ANC:

7D03

Relief:

Pursuant To:

Case Type:

Appeal

Case Status:

Active

Result:

Deny 4 - 0 - 1

Past Hearing Date(s):

12/18/2019, 11/20/2019, 11/13/2019

Property Information:

Square	Lot(s)
5097	846

Project Image

Map Inset

Exhibits

row_num#	Exhibit #	Exhibit Description	Number of Pages	Exhibit Date	Action
1	1	Application Form	1	8/21/2019	View
2	2	Application Form 125	2	08/16/2019	View
3	3	Statement of Appeal	4	8/14/2019	View
4	4	Application Form 125 - Manual Form Filled Out	2	08/16/2019	View
5	5	FOIA Request Ex 11-13 Scan	53	8/14/2019	View
6	6	Ex 9 and 10	11	8/14/2019	View
7	7	Ex 14	4	8/14/2019	View
8	8	Matt LeGrant, Zoning Administrator - DCRA Decision	1	8/14/2019	View
9	9	Certificate of Service	1	8/15/2019	View
10	10	Explanation of Opposition , Caselaw and Facts	10	08/16/2019	View
11	11	Receipt	1	9/5/2019	View
12	12	Letter in Opposition of Appeal from Valor Minnesota, LLC	2	09/11/2019	View
13	13	ANC 7D Report	3	09/12/2019	View
14	14	BZA Referral/PHN to ANC 7D	2	09/23/2019	View
15	15	BZA Referral/PHN to ANCSMD 7D03	2	09/23/2019	View
16	16	BZA Referral to OANC	1	09/23/2019	View
17	17	BZA Referral to OP	1	09/23/2019	View
18	18	BZA Referral/PHN to DCRA	2	09/23/2019	View
19	19	BZA Referral/PHN to Council of the District of Columbia, Ward 7	2	09/23/2019	View
20	20	BZA Referral to Councilmember, At-Large ( Elissa Silverman)	1	09/23/2019	View
21	21	BZA Referral to Councilmember, At-Large (David Grosso)	1	09/23/2019	View
22	22	BZA Referral to Councilmember, At-Large (Anita Bonds)	1	09/23/2019	View
23	23	BZA Referral to Councilmember, At-Large (Robert White, Jr.)	1	09/23/2019	View
24	24	BZA Referral to Chairman of the Council (Phil Mendelson)	1	09/23/2019	View
25	25	BZA PHN to Appellant (Dorothy Douglas)	2	09/23/2019	View
26	26	BZA PHN to Property Owner (Valor Minnesota, LLC)	2	09/23/2019	View
27	27	Property Owner's Letter of Authorization	3	11/6/2019	View
28	28	DCRA's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	7	11/6/2019	View
29	29	BZA Memo Postponing Appeal to a DATE TO BE DETERMINED	1	11/07/2019	View
30	30	BZA Memo Postponing Hearing to November 20, 2019	1	11/08/2019	View
31	31	ANC 7D Report	1	11/13/2019	View
32	32	Email Correspondence Re: Postponement	3	11/15/2019	View
33	33	Color Photographs Before Permit was Issued on 9/23/2019	12	11/18/2019	View
34	34	Color Photographs of Vehicles Not Associated with Ft. Meyers	6	11/18/2019	View
35	35	Copies of Permits	5	11/18/2019	View
36	36	Email Chain Re: Building Permit B1903246	2	11/18/2019	View
37	36A	Building Permit B1903246	2	11/18/2019	View
38	37	Email Correspondence	2	11/18/2019	View
39	38	Additional Email Correspondence	6	11/18/2019	View
40	39	Copy of Tree Removal Permit TA82413	4	11/18/2019	View
41	40	Email Correspondence	2	11/18/2019	View
42	41	Building Permit Report for ANC 7D	6	11/18/2019	View
43	42	Email Correspondence Re: Statement of the Appellant	2	11/18/2019	View
44	42A	Statement of the Property Owner	6	11/18/2019	View
45	43	Color Photographs	4	11/18/2019	View
46	44	Email Correspondence Re: Testimony of Dorothy Douglas	1	11/18/2019	View
47	44A	Testimony of Dorothy Douglas	2	11/18/2019	View
48	45	Legal Update	7	11/18/2019	View
49	46	Additional Color Photographs	4	11/18/2019	View
50	47	Email Correspondence Re: ANC Meeting Agenda	2	11/18/2019	View
51	47A	ANC Meeting Agenda	1	11/18/2019	View
52	48	Additional Color Photograph	1	11/18/2019	View
53	49	Email Correspondence Re: Letter in Opposition from Jane Zara	3	11/18/2019	View
54	49A	Letter in Opposition from Jane Zara	17	11/18/2019	View
55	50	Email Correspondence Re: Text	2	11/18/2019	View
56	51	Email Correspondence Re: Letter from Greer Johnson Gillis	2	11/18/2019	View
57	51A	Letter from Greer Johnson Gillis	6	11/18/2019	View
58	52	Email Correspondence Re: Community Opposition Presentation	3	11/18/2019	View
59	52A	Community Opposition Presentation	8	11/18/2019	View
60	53	Email Correspondence Re: Dorothy Douglas Letter to Gillis Environmental Study Request	1	11/18/2019	View
61	53A	Dorothy Douglas Letter to Gillis Environmental Study Request	1	11/18/2019	View
62	54	Email Correspondence Re: Revised Dorothy Douglas Letter to Gillis Environmental Study Request	2	11/18/2019	View
63	54A	Revised Dorothy Douglas Letter to Gillis Environmental Study Request	3	11/18/2019	View
64	55	Email Correspondence Re: Raze Application Report	6	11/18/2019	View
65	56	Architectural Plans and Elevations	14	11/18/2019	View
66	57	Construction Permit #1	13	11/18/2019	View
67	58	Construction Permit #2	7	11/18/2019	View
68	59	Raze Permits	3	11/18/2019	View
69	60	ANC 7D03 Meeting Brochure	7	11/19/2019	View
70	61	Color Photographs	2	11/19/2019	View
71	62	Environmental Assessment	22	11/19/2019	View
72	63	Letter from ANC 7D/7D03 Requesting Environmental Soil Contamination Testing	3	11/19/2019	View
73	64	Letter from DCRA	3	11/19/2019	View
74	65	Copy of Kevin Hugel's Business Card	1	11/19/2019	View
75	66	Color Photographs of Apartment Fire Nov. 16,2019	10	11/19/2019	View
76	67	Color Photographs of Traffic Nov. 16, 2019	9	11/19/2019	View
77	68	Color Photographs of Public Spaces Blocked	6	11/19/2019	View
78	69	Additional Color Photograph	1	11/19/2019	View
79	70	Color Photographs of DCRA's Posted Signs	4	11/19/2019	View
80	71	Color Photographs of Violations	7	11/19/2019	View
81	72	Color Photographs of Violations #2	10	11/19/2019	View
82	73	Color Photographs of Violation #3	2	11/19/2019	View
83	74	Additional Color Photographs	4	11/19/2019	View
84	75	Additional Color Photographs #2	2	11/19/2019	View
85	76	Additional Color Photographs #3	6	11/19/2019	View
86	77	Additional Color Photographs #4	6	11/19/2019	View
87	78	Color Photographs of No Permits Posted and No Raze Permits	3	11/19/2019	View
88	79	Additional Color Photographs #5	10	11/19/2019	View
89	80	Motion to Oppose and Appeal DCRA's Determination Letter	3	11/20/2019	View
90	81	Witness Cards	2	11/20/2019	View
91	82	BZA Memo - Closed Record Except for Documents Requested	1	11/22/2019	View
92	83A1	Cover Letter from Property Owner Enclosing Updated Architectural Plans (Part 1)	13	11/22/2019	View
93	83A2	Cover Letter from Property Owner Enclosing Updated Architectural Plans (Part 2)	27	11/22/2019	View
94	84	DCRA's Praecipe	3	11/27/2019	View
95	85	Appellant's Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law & Documents	91	12/06/2019	View
96	85A	Appellant's Statement of Facts w/Accompanying Exhibits	23	12/06/2019	View
97	85A1	Site Plan - Duplicate to graphics in Ex. 85 (pages 33-38)	5	12/06/2019	View
98	85B1	List of Exhibits (Part 1)	108	12/06/2019	View
99	85B2	List of Exhibit (Part 2)	76	12/06/2019	View
100	86	Property Owner's Proposed Finding of Facts	2	12/09/2019	View
101	86A	Proposed Finding of Facts to DCRA's Motion to Dismiss	11	12/09/2019	View
102	86B	Proposed Finding of Facts as to Substance of the Appeal	8	12/09/2019	View
103	87	DCRA's Proposed Finding of Facts	14	12/09/2019	View
104	87A	Exhibit to DCRA's Proposed Finding of Facts	5	12/09/2019	View
105	88	Property Owners Motion to Strike Documents Submitted by Appellant	2	12/09/2019	View
106	89	Appellant's Response to Valor's Motion to Strike New Evidence	9	12/16/2019	View

Orders

No Order(s) found

No Order(s) found

Transcripts

Transcript Date	Meeting Type	Action
12/18/2019	Public Meeting	View
11/20/2019	Public Hearing	View

Videos

Related Videos
We could not found any videos. Click here to search for past hearings by using DCOZ Video On Demand tool.

DC Office of Zoning

Office of Zoning
202-727-6311
[email protected]

Office of Planning

Office of Planning
202-442-7600
[email protected]

ANC

7D
BRIAN ALCORN
Visit Website

SMD

7D03
ARTILIE WRIGHT
Visit Website

Case 20141