Case 19-10

Case Overview
Application of:   Valor Development, LLC
Case Summary:   Consolidated PUD, bounded by Yuma St., Massachusetts Ave., 48th St. NW, & the Spring Valley Exxon Station, "Lady Bird" (Sq. 1499, Lots 802, 803, 806, & 807) - Ward 3
Consolidated PUD, bounded by Yuma St., Massachusetts Ave., 48th St. NW, & the Spring Valley Exxon Station, "Lady Bird" (Sq. 1499, Lots 802, 803, 806, & 807) - Ward 3
ANC:   3D03 3E02
Case Type:   Consolidated PUD
Case Status:   Closed
Result:   Approve(5-0-0)
Past Hearing Date(s):   10/10/2019, 10/10/2019, 10/07/2019, 09/19/2019
Past Meeting Date(s):   10/10/2019, 10/10/2019, 10/07/2019, 09/19/2019, 06/10/2019
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
14990802
14990803
14990806
14990807
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Cvr. Ltr. from Applicant - Consolidated PUD Application305/06/2019View
22Statement in Support3005/06/2019View
32ASIS: Tab A (Zoning Map)105/06/2019View
42BSIS: Tab. B (Surveyors Plat)105/06/2019View
52C1SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 1)2105/06/2019View
62C2SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 2)1005/06/2019View
72C3SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings -Part 3)405/06/2019View
82C4SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 4)405/06/2019View
92C5SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings -Part 5)705/06/2019View
102C6SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 6)1305/06/2019View
112C7SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 7)805/06/2019View
122C8SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 8)805/06/2019View
132C9SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 9)505/06/2019View
142C10SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 10)1005/06/2019View
152C11SIS: Tab C (Architectural Drawings - Part 11)905/06/2019View
162DSIS: Tab D (Future Land Use Map)105/06/2019View
172ESIS: Tab E (Generalized Policy Map)105/06/2019View
182FSIS: Tab F (Summary of Compliance with Comprehensive Plan)1605/10/2019View
192GSIS: Tab G (Application Form)105/06/2019View
202HSIS: Tab. H (Authorization Ltrs.)405/06/2019View
212ISIS: Tab I (Certificate of Notice, Notice of Intent, List of Property Owners within 200 feet)505/06/2019View
223Copy of Filing Fee105/07/2019View
234Ltr. of Acceptance to Applicant105/14/2019View
245Referral to OP105/14/2019View
256Referral to Councilmember Mary Cheh105/14/2019View
267Referral to ANC 3D and 3E705/14/2019View
278NOF to DC Register105/14/2019View
289Attestation: NOF205/14/2019View
2910Comments from Councilmember Cheh105/24/2019View
3011OP Setdown Report1905/31/2019View
3112Prehearing Statement86/17/2019View
3212APHS: Tab A (List of Witnesses)16/17/2019View
3312BPHS: Tab B (Witness Testimony Outlines and Experts' Resumes)106/17/2019View
3412CPHS: Tab C (List of Maps)16/17/2019View
3512DPHS: Tab D (200 Ft POL)26/17/2019View
3612EReceipt for Hearing Fee106/17/2019View
3713Certificate of Service (PHS)16/17/2019View
3814Proof of Publication of PHN in D.C. Register106/20/2019View
3915Notice of Public Hearing406/20/2019View
4016Attestation: PHN306/25/2019View
4117CRD - Request for Party Status in Opposition and Advanced Consideration (APPROVED)147/1/2019View
42181 Returned PHN207/03/2019View
4319Request from CRD Re: Expert Witnesses97/25/2019View
4420Notice of Rescheduled Public Hearing407/25/2019View
4521Proof of Publication of Rescheduled Public Hearing Notice in D.C. Register107/25/2019View
46221 Returned PHN208/08/2019View
4723Attestation: Rescheduled PHN307/30/2019View
4824Affidavit of Posting78/19/2019View
4925Cvr. Ltr. from Applicant - Transportation Study49/3/2019View
5025ACTR879/3/2019View
5125BCTR Technical Appendix2929/3/2019View
5225CResumes of Erwin Andres & Daniel Soloman39/3/2019View
5326ANC 3D Report1209/06/2019View
54271 Returned PHN209/11/2019View
5528Applicant's Supplemental Prehearing Statement79/17/2019View
5628A1SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-1)209/17/2019View
5728A2SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-2)109/17/2019View
5828A3SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-3)49/17/2019View
5928A4SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-4)49/17/2019View
6028A5SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-5)69/17/2019View
6128A6SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-6)149/17/2019View
6228A7SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-7)99/17/2019View
6328A8SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-8)49/17/2019View
6428A9SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-9)69/17/2019View
6528A10SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-10)39/17/2019View
6628A11SPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawings - Part-11)109/17/2019View
6729Ltr. in Opposition - Irene and Tony Diamond109/19/2019View
6830Letter in Opposition from Huma Malik209/19/2019View
6931Request for Party Status in Support - Ward 3 Vision69/20/2019View
7032Ltr. in Opposition - Nanda Kulathunga109/20/2019View
7133Request for Party Status in Opposition - SVWHCA and NLC79/20/2019View
7234Party Status Request in Support - SVNA49/20/2019View
7335Ltr. in Opposition - Alain Locussol and Noriko Iwase209/23/2019View
7436Ltr. in Opposition - Page Palmer109/23/2019View
7537Ltr. in Opposition - Anthony and Eileen Essaye209/24/2019View
7638Ltr. in Opposition - Deborah G. Barry and Carlos DC Ferreira209/25/2019View
7739Letter in Opposition - Sylvia E. Josif109/24/2019View
7840Ltr. in Opposition - Olga M. Gazda109/24/2019View
7941Ltr. in Opposition - John and Eileen Verna109/24/2019View
8042Ltr. in Opposition - Paul and Susanne Koffsky209/25/2019View
8143Ltr. in Opposition - Patricia E. Kolesar309/26/2019View
8244Ltr. in Opposition - Michael Stover209/26/2019View
8345Ltr. in Opposition - TNA29/26/2019View
8446Ltr. in Opposition - Grant Michael Dixon109/26/2019View
8547Ltr. in Opposition - Claudia Taubman209/26/2019View
8648ANC 3E Resolution309/27/2019View
8749Memorandum of Understanding (Submitted by ANC 3E)1009/27/2019View
8850Draft Parking Management Plan (Submitted by ANC 3E)209/27/2019View
8951Ltr. in Opposition - Aidan Jones109/27/2019View
9052DDOT Report209/27/2019View
9153OP Final Hearing Report299/27/2019View
9254Ltr. in Opposition - Larry Reicher109/27/2019View
9355Ltr. in Opposition - Ann Stansbury209/28/2019View
9456Ltr. in Opposition - Yvonne Dixon109/30/2019View
9557Ltr. in Support - Helen and John Lyons109/30/2019View
9658Ltr. in Support - Rahul Bhat109/30/2019View
9759Ltr. in Support - Nancy Meakem209/30/2019View
9860Ltr. in Support - Elan Blutinger109/30/2019View
9961Ltr. in Support - Hashim Hassan209/30/2019View
10062Ltr. in Support - Jennifer Grosman209/30/2019View
10163Ltr. in Support - Sara Switzer109/30/2019View
10264Ltr. in Support - Robin Stiner109/30/2019View
10365Ltr. in Opposition - Laura Garces Fischer109/30/2019View
10466Ltr. in Opposition - Charlotte LeGates409/30/2019View
10567Ltr. in Opposition - Ann and Richard Gregory 209/30/2019View
10668Ltr. in Support - Linda Laniado and Jerry Stevens209/30/2019View
10769Ltr. in Opposition - Etienne Linard109/30/2019View
10870Ltr. in Opposition - Thu-Ha Huynh109/30/2019View
10971Ltr. in Opposition - Christoph Klingen109/30/2019View
11072Ltr. in Support - David and Mary Ritchey109/30/2019View
11173Ltr. in Support - Amy Jagodnik109/30/2019View
11274Ltr. in Opposition - Jose M. Alonso-Biarge and Laura Alonso, ABE Holdings, LLC109/30/2019View
11375Ltr. in Support - Carmel Greer AIA, LEED, AP109/30/2019View
11476Ltr. in Opposition - Marilyn Richert209/30/2019View
11577Ltr. in Opposition - Margaret B. Parlato209/30/2019View
11678Ltr. in Support - Dr. Robert B. Hufnagel, MD, PhD109/30/2019View
11779Ltr. in Opposition - Barbara and Shelly Repp209/30/2019View
11880Ltr. in Support - Carroll Cavanagh109/30/2019View
11981Ltr. in Opposition - Doug and Mary Ann Barnes909/30/2019View
12082Ltr. in Support - Ari Firoozabadi109/30/2019View
12183Ltr. in Support - John Stiner109/30/2019View
12284Ltr. in Support - Tamara A. Katy, MD, FAAP110/01/2019View
12385Ltr. in Support - Sandra Normann-Kravitz110/01/2019View
12486Written Testimony in Support - Ellen Bass210/01/2019View
12587Ltr. in Opposition - Jane Petit-Moore110/01/2019View
12688Ltr. in Opposition - Federico Mordini510/01/2019View
12789Ltr. in Opposition - Milton Buchler II510/01/2019View
12890Letter in Opposition - Sondra Mills210/1/2019View
12991Ltr. in Support - Eric Tracy110/01/2019View
13092Ltr. in Opposition - Giles Kelly, Captain USNR, Retired210/01/2019View
13193Ltr. in Opposition - Frederick (Rick) Steinheiser, Jr. PhD210/02/2019View
13294Ltr. in Opposition - Eric S. Yambrusic, Esq. (Submitted by Rick Steinheiser, Jr. PhD on his Behalf)210/02/2019View
13395Ltr. in Opposition - Phyllis Kline210/02/2019View
13496Ltr. in Opposition - Thu-Ha Huynh Linard110/02/2019View
13597Ltr. in Opposition - Charles F. Reusch210/02/2019View
13698Ltr. in Support - Marguerite Clarkson110/02/2019View
13799Ltr. in Opposition - Richard Tatum2510/02/2019View
138100Ltr. in Opposition - Kathleen A. Felton and Wayne L. Mock310/02/2019View
139101Ltr. in Opposition - Elizabeth H. Mohre210/02/2019View
140102Ltr. in Support - Alan van Order110/02/2019View
141103Ltr. in Support - Hilary Chapman110/03/2019View
142104Ltr. in Support - John Clarkson110/03/2019View
143105Ltr. in Support - James Calomiris110/03/2019View
144106Ltr. in Support - JoAnn and George Calomiris110/03/2019View
145107Ltr. in Support - E. Cory Miller110/03/2019View
146108Ltr. in Support - Bo Blair110/03/2019View
147109Ltr. in Opposition - Walter Borek110/03/2019View
148110Ltr. in Support - Saba Moritz110/03/2019View
149111Ltr. in Support - Lindsey Drath110/03/2019View
150112Ltr. in Support - Stacy & Eric Patlovich110/03/2019View
151113Ltr. in Support - Kathryn Barnes110/03/2019View
152114Ltr. in Support - Kelly Frekko110/03/2019View
153115Ltr. in Support - Carol Boochever110/03/2019View
154116Ltr. in Support - Mark Amorosi110/03/2019View
155117Ltr. in Support - Austin Branson110/03/2019View
156118Statement in Opposition - CRD4710/3/2019View
157119Ltr. in Support - Courtney Byrd Metz110/03/2019View
158120Ltr. in Support - Nathan Imperiale110/03/2019View
159121Ltr. in Support - Sharon Amorosi110/03/2019View
160122Ltr. in Support - Mary Kathryn Steel110/03/2019View
161123Ltr. in Support - William Fastow210/03/2019View
162124CRD's Response to Transportation Report1710/3/2019View
163125Ltr. in Support - Jenny and Willie Gaynor110/03/2019View
164126Ltr. in Support - Lauren Pillsbury110/03/2019View
165127Ltr. in Opposition - Keisha Hylton-Rodic410/03/2019View
166128Ltr. in Support - Lauren Ashburn110/03/2019View
167129Ltr. in Support - John Frekko110/03/2019View
168130Ltr. in Support - Rory Pillsbury110/03/2019View
169131Ltr. in Opposition - 200 Footers510/03/2019View
170132Ltr. in Support - Chris & Deb Gill110/03/2019View
171133Ltr. in Support - Wendy Messenger110/03/2019View
172134Ltr. in Support - Ronald Eichner110/03/2019View
173135Ltr. in Opposition - George Hager210/03/2019View
174136Ltr. in Support - Samantha Mazo and Alex Gordon110/03/2019View
175137Ltr. in Support - Christopher & Elizabeth Forte110/03/2019View
176138Ltr. in Support - Patricia Alonso-Gamo110/03/2019View
177139Ltr. in Support- Pat Cave110/03/2019View
178140Ltr. in Support - Kathleen Gallagher110/03/2019View
179141Ltr. in Support - Ashley Bronczek110/04/2019View
180142Ltr. in Support - Allison Feeney110/04/2019View
181143Ltr. in Support - Sandy Nelson310/04/2019View
182144Ltr. in Opposition - Jason Mitchell210/04/2019View
183145Ltr. in Support - Robbie Brooks210/04/2019View
184146Ltr. in Support - Oren Goldberg110/04/2019View
185147Ltr. in Support - Matthew McMahon110/04/2019View
186148Ltr. in Support - Brett Orlove110/04/2019View
187149Ltr. in Support - John Wheeler110/4/2019View
188150Affidavit of Maintenance610/01/2019View
189151Cvr. Ltr. from Applicant - Response to OP and DDOT Reports910/4/2019View
190151AResponse: Tab A (Updated PUD Flexibility)210/4/2019View
191151BResponse: Tab B (Updated Benefits List)710/4/2019View
192151CResponse: Tab C (Updated Architectural Sheets)910/4/2019View
193152Comments from NLC1610/04/2019View
194153Ltr. in Support - Kathryn Fioravanti210/04/2019View
195154A1ANC 3E's PowerPoint Presentation (Part 1)3010/04/2019View
196154A2ANC 3E's PowerPoint Presentation (Part 2)1010/04/2019View
197154A3ANC 3E's PowerPoint Presentation (Part 3)2110/04/2019View
198154A4ANC 3E's PowerPoint Presentation (Part 4)810/04/2019View
199155Ltr. in Opposition - Monica Healy210/04/2019View
200156Ltr. in Support - CSG410/4/2019View
201157Ltr. in Support - Ward 3 Vision210/6/2019View
202158Ltr. in Opposition - WCA110/07/2019View
203159Ltr. in Support - Saraswati Gandhi110/07/2019View
204160Ltr. in Support - Nicole Mlade110/07/2019View
205161Ltr. in Support - Kerry and Alexander Troup110/07/2019View
206162Ltr. in Support - Elan Blutinger110/07/2019View
207163Ltr. in Support - Joshua Miller110/07/2019View
208164Ltr. in Support - Sarah and Chris Cannova110/07/2019View
209165Ltr. in Support - Katherine Engelhard Pingree110/07/2019View
210166Ltr. in Opposition - Peter McCarthy210/07/2019View
211167Ltr. in Support - Wes Boatwright310/07/2019View
212168Ltr. in Support - Jordan Tama110/07/2019View
213169Ltr. in Support - Elizabeth Werner110/07/2019View
214170Ltr. in Support - Carl Kravitz110/07/2019View
215171Ltr. in Support - Kevin Reynolds110/07/2019View
216172Ltr. in Support - Charles D. Nottingham110/07/2019View
217173Ltr. in Support - Jennifer Rudy110/07/2019View
218174Ltr. in Opposition - Laura Ivers110/07/2019View
219175Ltr. in Support - Carolyn Howe110/07/2019View
220176Ltr. in Support - Jennie Bonney110/07/2019View
221177Ltr. in Opposition - Lauren Sun & Francesco Valentini7810/07/2019View
222178Ltr. in Support - Richard L. Michaux110/07/2019View
223179Ltr. in Support - Anne Vinson110/07/2019View
224180Ltr. in Opposition - Ann Kelly210/07/2019View
225181Ltr. in Authorization - SVWHCA110/07/2019View
226182Ltr. in Support - Shippen Howe110/07/2019View
227183Ltr. in Support - Fred Vinson110/07/2019View
228184Ltr. in Opposition - Marianne Siemietkowski Needham210/07/2019View
229185Ltr. in Opposition - SVWHCA1310/7/2019View
230186Testimony of Douglas Barnes210/07/2019View
231186APowerPoint Presentation from Douglas Barnes1710/07/2019View
232187HPRB Report210/7/2019View
233188Ltr. in Support - Ross M. Dunlap110/07/2019View
234189Ltr. in Opposition - Eli Borek110/07/2019View
235190Ltr. in Support - Jay Gribble110/07/2019View
236191Ltr. in Support - Leanita Shelby110/07/2019View
237192Ltr. in Support - Arthur Ott110/07/2019View
238192A2nd Ltr. in Support - Arthur Ott110/07/2019View
239193Ltr. in Opposition - Emily Koffsky210/07/2019View
240194Applicants PowerPoint Presentation6710/7/2019View
241195Applicants Photo of Materials Board310/7/2019View
242196Email Comments in Opposition - Alexander & Chahnaz McRae110/07/2019View
243197Email Comments in Opposition - Elizabeth Mitchell210/07/2019View
244198Email Comments in Opposition - Elizabeth & Kevin Callanan110/07/2019View
245199Email Comments in Support - Donald Clark110/07/2019View
246200Testimony of Jonathan McHugh, ANC 3E310/07/2019View
247200AANC 3E's PowerPoint Presentation510/10/2019View
248201Testimony of Troy Kravitz, ANC 3D310/07/2019View
249202Witness Cards410/07/2019View
250203Ltr. in Opposition - Marilyn Richert110/08/2019View
251204Ltr. in Support - Marni Carroll110/08/2019View
252205Ltr. from Sondra Mills - Clarifying Record110/8/2019View
253206DC Rent Control Report3510/8/2019View
254207Ltr. in Opposition - Richard Tatum2610/09/2019View
255208Ltr. in Support - Shane Mulhern110/09/2019View
256209Ltr. in Opposition - Isabelle de Zamaroczy110/09/2019View
257210Ltr. in Opposition - Kendall Heath210/09/2019View
258211Ltr. in Opposition - Michael Truscott110/10/2019View
259212Ltr. in Opposition - Thomas Smith110/10/2019View
260213Testimony - SVWHCA610/10/2019View
261214Ltr. in Opposition - Christopher Simpson210/10/2019View
262215Preservation Matters (CRD) Response to HPO Report510/10/2019View
263216CRD's PowerPoint Presentation2810/10/2019View
264217CRD's Visual Impact Study PowerPoint Presentation1010/10/2019View
265218ANC 3D's Response to Digression on Rent Control210/10/2019View
266219Ltr. in Opposition - Myrna Sislen110/10/2019View
267220List of Witnesses (10-10-19)210/10/2019View
268221Testimony in Support - William Clarkson, SVNA310/10/2019View
269222Testimony in Opposition - Richard Tatum210/10/2019View
270223Testimony in Opposition - Milton Buchler II210/10/2019View
271224Testimony in Opposition - Alexander McRae and Chahnaz McRae110/10/2019View
272225Testimony in Opposition - Aidan Jones110/10/2019View
273226Testimony in Opposition - Walter Borek1410/10/2019View
274227Ltr. in Support - Krista Di Iaconi, Regency Centers110/10/2019View
275228Witness Cards410/10/2019View
276229Applicant's Rebuttal PowerPoint Presentation2010/14/2019View
277230Cvr. Ltr. from Applicant - Proffers and Conditions310/17/2019View
278230AApplicant's Proposed Proffers and Conditions1310/17/2019View
279231ANC 3D Post-Hearing Statement910/17/2019View
280232ATestimony in Opposition - Shelly Repp510/21/2019View
281232BTestimony in Opposition - Ann Stansbury310/21/2019View
282232CTestimony in Opposition - Barbara Repp610/21/2019View
283233DCOZ Email to Parties re: Additional Requested Information210/17/2019View
284234Testimony in Support - W3V310/22/2019View
285235W3V's Post-Hearing Statement510/22/2019View
286236SVWHCA & NLC's Comments On Proffers and Benefits1410/24/2019View
287237Affordable Housing Comments from SVWHCA-NLC310/24/2019View
288238CRD's Post-Hearing Submission3510/24/2019View
289239CRD's Response to Applicant's Proffers w CL1510/24/2019View
290240SVNA's Post-Hearing Submission310/24/2019View
291241Cvr. Ltr. from the Applicant - Post-Hearing Statement1010/24/2019View
292241AAPHS: Tab A (Architectural Drawing Sheets)1910/24/2019View
293241BAPHS: Tab B (American U. Park Citizens Assn v Burka)1710/24/2019View
294241CAPHS: Tab C (Declaration of Easement and Agreement)910/24/2019View
295241DAPHS: Tab D (Response to OAG)4210/24/2019View
296242Ltr. from SVWHCO - Request for More Time to Respond to Applicant's Post-Hearing Submission (APPROVED 3 MORE DAYS TO PARTIES SERVED BY MAIL)210/29/2019View
297243Ward3Vision's Response to Opponent's Post-Hearing Submission410/31/2019View
298244CRD's Response to Applicant's Post-Hearing Submission4210/31/2019View
299245Cvr. Ltr. from Applicant - Revised Proffers and Conditions310/31/2019View
300245AApplicant's Revised Proffers and Conditions1510/31/2019View
301246Applicant's Response to CRD/SVO Post-Hearing Submission1010/31/2019View
302247SVO's Response to Applicant's Post-Hearing Submission1311/4/2019View
303248CRD's Response to Applicant's Revised Proffers311/4/2019View
304249Applicant's Motion to Strike CRD's Shadow Study511/5/2019View
305250CRD's Opposition to Applicant's Motion to Strike211/7/2019View
306251SVNA's Support for Applicant's Motion to Strike211/11/2019View
307252W3V Response in Support of Applicant's Motion to Strike211/11/2019View
308253Citizens for Responsible Development's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law4011/12/2019View
309254Applicant's Draft Order6111/12/2019View
310255OZ's Procedural Memo to File211/19/2019View
311256Applicant's Response to CRD Shadow Study611/25/2019View
312256AApplicant's Response to CRD Shadow Study Exhibit A811/25/2019View
313257Spring Valley Opponents' Response to Applicant's Response to CRD Shadow Study412/2/2019View
314258CRD's Reply to the Applicant’s Response to CRD’s Shadow Study1812/2/2019View
315259Proof of Publication of Order in D.C. Register102/12/2020View
316260Z.C. Order No. 19-107302/12/2020View
317261Attestation: Order No. 19-10106/22/2020View
Orders
OrdersAction
Z.C. Order No. 19-10View
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
12/09/2019Public MeetingView
11/18/2019Public MeetingView
10/10/2019Public HearingView
10/07/2019Public HearingView
07/29/2019Public MeetingView
06/10/2019Public MeetingView
Videos
Related Videos
We could not found any videos. Click here to search for past hearings by using DCOZ Video On Demand tool.
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
3D
BERNIE HORN
Visit Website
SMD