Case 17109A

Case Overview
Application of:   Kalorama Citizens Association,
Case Summary:   Appeal No. 17109 of Kalorama Citizens Association, pursuant to 11 DCMR section3100 from the administrative decision of David Clarke, Director, Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs, from the issuance of Building Permit Nos. B455571 and B455876, dated October 6 and 16, 2003, respectively, to Montrose, LLC to adjust the building height to 70 feet and to revise penthouse roof structure plans to construct an apartment building in the R-5-D District at 1819 Belmont Road, N.W., Washington, D.C. and from the issuance of the original Building Permit No. B449218, dated March 11,2003.
Appeal No. 17109 of Kalorama Citizens Association, pursuant to 11 DCMR section3100 from the administrative decision of David Clarke, Director, Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs, from the issuance of Building Permit Nos. B455571 and B455876, dated October 6 and 16, 2003, respectively, to Montrose, LLC to adjust the building height to 70 feet and to revise penthouse roof structure plans to construct an apartment building in the R-5-D District at 1819 Belmont Road, N.W., Washington, D.C. and from the issuance of the original Building Permit No. B449218, dated March 11,2003.
Address:  
ANC:   1C,03
Relief:  
Pursuant To:  
Case Type:   Appeal
Case Status:   Closed
Result:   See Order
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
25510045
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11BZA Appeal Form 125111/10/2003View
22Copy of (C of O) Certificate of Occupancy with Plan of Building Site 411/10/2003View
33Copy of C of O with Plan Showing Revision211/10/2003View
442 C of O's of Bldg. Permits for 10/06&16/2003111/10/2003View
55Certificate of Service Mailed to Parties111/10/2003View
66Statement in Which Appellant is Aggrieved111/10/2003View
77Acknowledged Form of Being Filed111/10/2003View
88Copy of Receipt111/10/2003View
99Referral to Office of Planning111/12/2003View
1010Referral to ANC 1C111/12/2003View
1111Referral to (ANC) Gottlieb Simon111/12/2003View
1212Referral to Ken Laden, DDOT111/12/2003View
1313Referral to City Councilmember, Ward 1111/12/2003View
1414Referral to ANC/SMD 1C03111/12/2003View
1515Referral to DCRA, David Clarke, Director 111/12/2003View
1616Letter from Jim Graham Councilmember, Ward 1212/08/2003View
1717Public Hearing Notice to ANC 1C312/17/2003View
1818Letter to Anne H. Hargrove, Kalorama Citizens Association Re: Hearing Date212/17/2003View
1919Letter to DCRA Re: Hearing Date212/17/2003View
2020Letter from Alan J. Roth Chairperson, ANC 1C, Re: Appeal of KCA from the Issuance of Bldg. Permits412/22/2003View
2121Letter from Donald Brooks in Opposition11/23/04View
2222Request for Party Status from Donald C. Brooks22/3/04View
2323Request for Party Status from Laura A. Gubisch42/3/04View
2424Request for Party Status from David Earl Wilton22/3/04View
2525Request for Party Status from James J. & Mary M. McAndrew22/3/04View
2626Request for Party Status from Ann Hughes & John Lawrence Hargrove22/3/04View
2727Request for Party Status from Jonathan Orloff22/3/04View
2828Request for Party Status from Gordon S. Swartz32/3/04View
2929Appellant's Statement Submitted by Ann Hughes Hargrove4902/03/2004View
3030Motion from Ann Hughes Hargrove, Zoning Chair, KCA402/09/2004View
3131Motion of Montrose LLC to Dismiss5002/17/2004View
3232Letter of Authorization102/17/2004View
3333Appellant's Chronology of the Case32/17/04View
3434Letter from D. Troy Boucher and Jeffrey Morrow102/17/2004View
3535Letter from Board of Directors of the Netherlands202/17/2004View
3636Witness Cards202/17/2004View
3737Joint Opposition of Appellant KCA & ANC 1C to Montrose LLC's Motion to Dismiss Submitted by Andrea C Ferster & Alan Roth, ANC 1CBook Form03/02/2004View
3838Declaration of Ann Hughes Hargrove and John Lawrence Hargrove submitted by Appellant Kalorama Citizens Association703/02/2004View
3940Witness Cards203/09/2004View
4041Kalorama Citizen's Association - Memorandum of Law on the Height Act4003/09/2004View
4142Webster Dictionary Definition "Attic"203/09/2004View
4243Definitions as Defined in BOCA -- Nat'l Building Code203/09/2004View
4344Photos Showing Subject Building203/09/2004View
4445Resume of Don A. Hawkins703/09/2004View
4546Statement of Ann Hughes Hargrove503/09/2004View
4647Floor Area Ratio Calculations from DCRA103/09/2004View
4748Supplemental Report of Don A. Hawkins, Architect Submission of Appellant KCA2503/15/2004View
4849Witness Cards103/16/2004View
4950Definition of Party Wall103/16/2004View
5052Witness Cards204/06/2004View
5153Definition of Structural as defined in Webster's204/06/2004View
5254Letter Filed by the ANC Identifying Difficulties in the ZA's Office304/06/2004View
5355Letter Filed by the ANC from Denise James304/06/2004View
5456Resume of Norman K. Smith204/06/2004View
5557Technical Memo Regarding Field Reading for Existing Building Elevation104/06/2004View
5658Developer's Bio - Gail Montplaisir104/06/2004View
5759Outline of Testimony of Gail Montplaisir204/06/2004View
5860Taurus Enterprise Group. Inc Backgroud104/06/2004View
5961Photos filed by the Property owner404/06/2004View
6062Plans from the Property owner404/06/2004View
6163Submission from the Appellant (2 Documents)7004/06/2004View
6264Appellee's request for extension of time to submit memorandum on jurisdiction of BZA to decide issues involving the height act submitted by Laura Gisolfi Gilbert204/13/2004View
6365Response of Intervenor montrose LLC to question of BZA's jurisdiction over 1910 height act submitted by Holland & Knight104/13/2004View
6466Appellee's submission to the Board regarding jurisdiction of the BZA submitted by Laura Gisolfi Gilbert1704/20/2004View
6567Letter from Laura Gisolfi Gilbert, Re: Affidavit submitted by former Zoning Administrator-Fahey dated 04/02/04.104/20/2004View
6668Witness Cards104/20/2004View
6769Appellant's Supplemental Memo of Law-Height of Bldg. Act.404/20/2004View
6870Resum'e of George H. F. Oberlandere Statement1404/20/2004View
6971Grade Plane Graphic104/20/2004View
7072Outline of what is on and is not included in GFA304/20/2004View
7173Letter from DCRA Requesting Extension of Time104/20/2004View
7274Orders of the BZA approving Roof Structures104/20/2004View
7375Letter from Ann Hughes Hargrove w/attached additional materials2404/26/2004View
7476Letter from Peter C. Schaumber in Opposition105/03/2004View
7577Appellant's response to Montrose LLC's Memorandum on BZA. Jurisdiction over height act issues submitted by Andrea C. Ferster705/11/2004View
7678Statement of Acting Zoning Administrator Denzil L. Noble105/11/2004View
7779Findings of Facts & Conclusion of Law Proposed by Appellant Kalorama Citizens Assoc. & ANC 1C submitted by Anne Hughes Hargrove2005/25/2004View
7880Letter from Carolyn Brown w/enclosed proposed order1905/25/2004View
7981Proposed findings of fact conclusion of law and order submitted by Laurie Gisolfi Gilbert805/25/2004View
8083Returned Materials to Ms. Brown & et al107/16/2004View
8184Letter from Mary Carolyn Brown, w/attachements, re: Motion fro partial reconsideration od decision on 6/22/04.5607/15/2004View
8285Letter to reopen the record in Appeal212/14/2004View
8386Memorandum of ANC 1C and Kalorama Citizens Assoc. in response to the Board's request for supplemental briefing of the exterior wall issue submitted by Alan J. Roth & Ann Hughes Hargrove311/11/05View
8487Letter from Holland & Knight w/enclosed intervenor's Brief on meaning of "Exterior Wall" under 1910 Height Act4701/11/2005View
8588Appellee's response to request by Board for additional breifing in issue of setbacks submitted by Laura Gisolfi Gilbert, Esq.501/11/2005View
8689Reply of ANC 1C & Kalorama Citizens Assoc. to response of Montrose LLC & DCRA to the Board's request submitted by Alan J. Roth & Ann Hughes Hargrove2101/25/2005View
8790Reply Brief of Intervenor Montrose, LLC on meaning of "Exterior Wall" submitted by Holland & Knight LLP1201/25/2005View
8891Final Order Granted in part and denied in part1711/08/2005View
8992Attestation211/08/2005View
9093Motion of Kalorama Citizens Association for Partial Rehearing and Reconsideration of Order of November 8, 2005, submitted by Ann Hughes Hargrove611/18/2005View
9194Answer of ANC 1C in support of Kalorama a Citizens Assoc. Motion for partial rehearing and reconsideration submitted by Alan J. Roth211/21/2005View
9295BZA Order No. 17109-A304/04/2006View
9396Attestation by Jerrily R. Kress204/04/2006View
9497Court Petition ( 06-AA-486)2405/12/2006View
9598Court Decision3011/21/2007View
9699BZA Procedural Order on Remand 17109-B406/14/2010View
97100Procedural Order on Demand406/14/2010View
98100AAttestation Letter from Jamison L. Weinbaum206/14/2010View
99102DCRA's memo in response to the Board's June 14, 2010 Procedural Order607/02/2010View
100103Request for waiver of July 2, 2010 filing deadline from ANC 1C Chair, Wilson Reynolds (unsigned)107/02/2010View
101104Certificate of Service of waiver request from ANC 1C Chair, Wilson Reynolds207/02/2010View
102105Letter form ANC-1C, Re: Remand to Appeal307/06/2010View
103105-ALetter from ANC-1C, Re: Remand to Appeal607/12/2010View
104106Letter from Mary Carolyn Brown, Re: remand from DC Court of Appeals307/12/2010View
105107Memo from Appellant-Kalorama Citizens Association, Re: Definition of Attic2307/12/2010View
106108Closed Record107/20/2010View
107109Letter to parties from BZA/Weinbaum transmitting the "Proposed Order" and permission to file exc.1001/07/2011View
108110Memorandum of appellant Kaloram Citizen's Association stating exceptions to proposed order on remand, submitted by John Lawrence Hargrove1202/04/2011View
109111DCRA's response to the proposed order, submitted by DCRA202/17/2011View
110112DCRA's response to appellant's exceptions, submitted by DCRA402/18/2011View
111113Reply of Appellant Kalorama Citizens Association to DCRA's response to KCA's exceptions to preposed order on remand from John L. Hargrove502/28/2011View
112114Witness Card104/05/2011View
113115BZA Notice of closed record after discussion104/05/2011View
114116Decision and Order After Remand806/15/2011View
115117Attestation Letter from Jamison L. Weinbaum206/15/2011View
116118Letter from BZA Requesting Drawings & Enclosure304/24/2014View
117119Letter from DCRA Re: Permit Drawings with Attachments in Response to BZA Letter of 4/24/20144507/03/2014View
118120Letter to Holland & Knight (Montrose-Intervenor) from BZA (Moy) Requesting Drawings307/14/2014View
119121Response Letter from Holland & Knight109/04/2014View
120122Order #1710917 View
121123Cover Letter and Attestation Transmitting Proposed Board Order to Parties for Exceptions1107/27/2017View
122124Exceptions to Proposed Order from ANC 1C and KCA3509/13/2017View
123125Decision and Order After Remand (17109-D) 01/24/2019View
124126Attestation 01/24/2019View
Orders
OrdersAction
Orders of the BZA approving Roof StructuresView
Proposed findings of fact conclusion of law and order submitted by Laurie Gisolfi GilbertView
Final Order Granted in part and denied in partView
Motion of Kalorama Citizens Association for Partial Rehearing and Reconsideration of Order of November 8, 2005, submitted by Ann Hughes HargroveView
BZA Order No. 17109-AView
123
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
10/28/2014Public HearingView
Videos
Related Videos
We could not found any videos. Click here to search for past hearings by using DCOZ Video On Demand tool.
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
1C
PETER WOOD
Visit Website
SMD