Case 08-15

Case Overview
Application of:   Friendship-Macomb
Case Summary:   Friendship-Macomb SC, Inc. - Consolidated PUD & Related Map Amendment from MW/C-1 & R-5-A to C-2-A & R-5-A, 3336, 3400-3430 & 3440 Wisconsin Ave. NW (Sq. 1920, Lot 831 and Sq. 1920N, Lots 1 & 2) - Giant
Friendship-Macomb SC, Inc. - Consolidated PUD & Related Map Amendment from MW/C-1 & R-5-A to C-2-A & R-5-A, 3336, 3400-3430 & 3440 Wisconsin Ave. NW (Sq. 1920, Lot 831 and Sq. 1920N, Lots 1 & 2) - Giant
ANC:   3C
Case Type:   Consolidated PUD & Related Map Amendment
Case Status:   Closed
Result:   See Order
Property Information:  
SquareLot(s)
19200001
19200002
19200831
1920N0001
1920N0002
1920N0831
Project Image
Map Inset
Exhibits
row_num#Exhibit #Exhibit DescriptionNumber of PagesExhibit DateAction
11Cover letter from Pillsbury205/16/2008View
22Copy of receipt of filing fee105/08/2008View
33Statement of Support3205/16/2008View
43A1Statement of Support; Tab A1 (Architectural Drawings, Elevations, and Photographs of the Subject Property and Surrounding Area)1205/16/2008View
53A2Statement of Support Tab; A2 (Architectural Drawings, Elevations, and Photographs of the Subject Property and Surrounding Area)2105/16/2008View
63BStatement of Support; Tab B (Existing and Proposed Zoning Map)205/16/2008View
73CStatement of Support; Tab C (Tabulations of Development Data and Public Benefits)405/16/2008View
83DStatement of Support; Tab D (Application Forms)405/16/2008View
93EStatement of Support; Tab E (Surveyor's Plats)205/16/2008View
103FStatement of Support; Tab F (Notice of Intent to Surrounding Property Owners and Certificate of Notice)405/16/2008View
113GStatement of Support; Tab G (Property Owners' List)505/16/2008View
123HStatement of Support; Tab H (Compliance with Consolidated PUD Requirements)205/16/2008View
133IStatement of Support; Tab I (Environmental Analysis)205/16/2008View
143JStatement of Support; Tab J (List of Publicly Available Information)105/16/2008View
153KStatement of Support; Tab K (Traffic Analysis by Wells & Associates)5605/16/2008View
163LStatement of Support; Tab L (Photographs of Existing Conditions)505/16/2008View
174Copy of mailing labels for property owners within 200 ft.205/16/2008View
185Letter of acceptance to applicant1 View
196Referral to OP1 View
207Referral to Councilmember Cheh1 View
218Referral to ANC 3C2 View
229Notice of Filing to DC Register2 View
2310Attestation of Notice of Filing2 View
2411OP Setdown report1407/18/2008View
2512Updated site plan and elevations507/21/2008View
2613Wisconsin Ave. Neighborhood Coalition's Cover Letter Enclosing Memorandum of Law1507/24/2008View
2714Letter of reconsideration of setdown from Frances A. Sciafani408/05/2008View
2815Response to request reconsideration of setdown309/03/2008View
2916Petition to refer case to BZA809/24/2008View
3017Motion to dismiss petition910/16/2008View
3118Letter enclosing signatures on attached petition4910/21/2008View
3219Applicant's cover letter310/27/2008View
3320Updated prehearing submission2710/27/2008View
3420AUpdated prehearing submission; Tab A (Architectural Drawings, Elevations, and Photographs of the Subject Property)3910/27/2008View
3520AA1Appendix A (Part 1 of 3)3910/27/2008View
3620AA2Appendix A (Part 2 of 3)3510/27/2008View
3720AA3Appendix A (Part 3 of 3)2310/27/2008View
3820BUpdated prehearing submission; Tab B (Tabulations of Development Data)410/27/2008View
3920CUpdated prehearing submission; Tab C (Environmental Checklists)1310/27/2008View
4020DUpdated prehearing submission; Tab D (Transportation and Parking Management Plan)210/27/2008View
4120EUpdated prehearing submission; Tab E (Truck Management Plan)210/27/2008View
4220FUpdated prehearing submission; Tab F (Traffic Impact Study Addendum, Wells & Associates)4010/27/2008View
4320GUpdated prehearing submission; Tab G (Property Owners' List)510/27/2008View
4420HUpdated prehearing submission; Tab H (List of Leaseholders)110/27/2008View
4520IUpdated prehearing submission; Tab I (List of Witnesses and Outlines of Witness Testimony)510/27/2008View
4620JUpdated prehearing submission; Tab J (List of Publicly Available Information)110/27/2008View
4720KUpdated prehearing submission; Tab K (Proposed First Source Employment Agreement)810/27/2008View
4821Cover letter and copy of hearing fee211/06/2008View
4922Public Hearing Notice to DC Register411/10/2008View
5023Petitioner's Letter in Opposition1011/14/2008View
5124Letter in Support from Mary Cheh211/12/2008View
5225Two Returned Public Hearing Notice411/24/2008View
5326Attestation: Public Hearing Notice611/13/2008View
5427Letter in opposition from Eleni Constantine312/15/2008View
5528Letter in opposition from Alfred Friendly, Jr.212/17/2008View
5629Letter in support from Laurence Aurbach112/18/2008View
5730DC Register: Corrected Public Hearing Notice412/22/2008View
5831Residents of ANC 3C Signed Petition112/30/2008View
5932Attestation: Public Hearing Notice and Copy of Labels612/31/2008View
6033Returned Public Hearing Notice201/05/2009View
6134Letter in support from McLean Gardens condominium101/07/2009View
6235Returned Public Hearing Notice201/12/2009View
6336Letter in concern submitted by Alice Powers101/12/2009View
6437Letter requesting ZC to expediate consideration of BZA referral1701/12/2009View
6538Letter in concern from Susan Jensen101/14/2009View
6639Letter in support from Peter W. Lande101/14/2009View
6740Affidavit of Posting1201/14/2009View
6841Returned Public Hearing Notice101/15/2009View
6942Letter in concern from Jane Bilchik101/21/2009View
7043Letter in concern from Lloyn and Ninette Feldman101/21/2009View
7144Letter in support from Nancy Herman101/26/2009View
7245Applicant's supplemental response to petition201/26/2009View
7346Supplemental Pre-Hearing Submission501/30/2009View
7446ASupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab A (Plan illustrating the relationship of the loading area to nearby residential property)201/30/2009View
7546BSupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab B (Noise Control Report)1501/30/2009View
7646CSupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab C (Sample of materials planned for each elevation)1201/30/2009View
7746DSupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab D (Proposed Guidelines for Storefronts and Signage)2001/30/2009View
7846ESupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab E (Outlines of Witnesses' Testimony)501/30/2009View
7946FSupplemental Pre-Hearing Submission; Tab F (Resumes of Expert Witnesses)1101/30/2009View
8047Letter in support from Nina Masson101/29/2009View
8148Letter in support from Helen C. Epps102/02/2009View
8249Letter in support from Theresa Fergo102/02/2009View
8350Request to appear and participate as a party in opposition802/02/2009View
8451Letter in Support from Ralph S. Cunningham102/02/2009View
8552Letter in Support from Scott Siff and Kinney Zalesne102/02/2009View
8653Letter in support from Susan and Ken Weinstein102/03/2009View
8754Letter in support from John McLean102/03/2009View
8855Letter requesting party status in opposition from Thomas J. Haines302/04/2009View
8956Letter in support from Robert Kerr202/04/2009View
9057Letter in support from Laszlo Bockn202/04/2009View
9158Letter in support from Jean P. Moore102/04/2009View
9259Letter requesting to participate as witnesses202/04/2009View
9360Letter in support from Sandra Burnis-Holly102/05/2009View
9461Ordway Street Neighbors Association requests to Participate as a Party in Opposition502/05/2009View
9562Letter in support from Janet Walker Chirlin1 View
9663Letter in concern submitted by Dorothy Rich102/05/2009View
9764An amended version of party status application from Thomas Haines702/05/2009View
9865Letter in support from Kara A. Lilian102/05/2009View
9966Letter in Support from Therese Fergo102/05/2009View
10067Request for Party Status Submitted by George Idelson202/05/2009View
10168Request for party status submitted by John B. Sullivan302/05/2009View
10269ANC 3C's resolution regarding PUD502/06/2009View
10370Letter in support from Shannon Sprague102/06/2009View
10471Letter in support from Dickson Carroll102/06/2009View
10572Letter in support from Rona Mendelson102/06/2009View
10673Letter in support from Kathy Dwyer102/06/2009View
10774Letter in support from Philip and Roberta Cronin202/06/2009View
10875Letter in support from Alan R. McMann102/06/2009View
10976Letter in support from Shane M. Gerson102/06/2009View
11077Letter in opposition from Patti McGill Peterson and Kate S. Woodward302/06/2009View
11178Letter in support from Matthew Wilshire and Laura Gonzales202/06/2009View
11279Letter in support from Joanna London102/06/2009View
11380Letter in support from Genie Gruhman102/09/2009View
11481Letter in support from Kirsten Melzger and Robbie Gilbert102/09/2009View
11582Letter in opposition from Thomas Jandl102/09/2009View
11683Letter in support from Madelyn E Spimak102/09/2009View
11784Letter in support from Joan Furlong and Stephen Tinius102/09/2009View
11885Letter of conditional support from Regina Markey302/09/2009View
11986Party Status Applicaiton - Advocates of Wisconsin Ave. renewal (AWARE)902/04/2009View
12087Fifty five signed petitions in support5502/04/2009View
12188Letter in support from Catherine Porter102/09/2009View
12289Letter in support/concern from Tom Graham202/09/2009View
12390Letter in support: Serena Viswanathan102/09/2009View
12491Letter in support: Louisa & William Newlin102/09/2009View
12592Letter in support: Newlin102/09/2009View
12693Letter in Support: Bassman202/09/2009View
12794Letter in support: Kerr202/09/2009View
12895Letter in support: Fineman102/09/2009View
12996Letter in support: Hansen102/09/2009View
13097Letter in support: Mendelson102/09/2009View
13198Letter in opposition: Rich102/09/2009View
13299Letter in support: Nye/Stevens102/09/2009View
133100Request for party status application602/09/2009View
134101Letter in support from Klaus and Janet Boese102/09/2009View
135102Letter in support/concern from Mary Warfield202/09/2009View
136103Letter in concern from Thomas Haines702/09/2009View
137104OP Report1002/09/2009View
138105Letter in support from Joshua Hart102/09/2009View
139106Letter in opposition from Stephanie Barton202/10/2009View
140107Letter in support from Mersfelder-Lewis102/10/2009View
141108Signed petition in support102/10/2009View
142109Letter in opposition - Guff102/10/2008View
143110Letter in support - Kursch102/10/2009View
144111Letter in support from Bell102/10/2009View
145112Letter in support - Moura102/10/2009View
146113Letter in support - Grohman102/10/2009View
147114Letter in support - Lilian102/10/2009View
148115Letter in concern from Feldman202/10/2009View
149116Letter in support - Oliver102/10/2009View
150117Testimony of Bairstow402/10/2009View
151118Letter in support from Roller202/10/2009View
152119Letter in support from Jones102/10/2009View
153120Letter in support - Palmiotto102/10/2009View
154121Letter in concern - Vanarsdall102/10/2009View
155122Letter in support - Plante102/10/2009View
156123Letter in support - Messerchmitt102/10/2009View
157124Letter in support - Davis202/10/2009View
158125Letter in support - Romanek102/11/2009View
159126Letter in opposition - Grano102/11/2009View
160127Testimony of Reeves202/11/2009View
161128Letter in support - Helm202/11/2009View
162129Letter in opposition - Bertrang102/10/2009View
163130Letter in concern - Montalto1202/10/2009View
164131Testimony in opposition - Schmenmann202/11/2009View
165132Mass Ave. Heights Citizens Assoc.'s Letter in Support - Cunningham102/11/2009View
166133Letter in support from Stovall102/11/2009View
167133Letter in support - Stovall102/11/2009View
168134Letter in support - Goff102/11/2009View
169135Letter in support - Doman102/11/2009View
170136Signed petitions in support602/11/2009View
171137Woodley Park Comm. Assoc. - Letter in support402/12/2009View
172138Letter in support - Griffin102/13/2009View
173139Letter in concern - Hacoche202/12/2009View
174140Letter in support - Oliver102/12/2009View
175141Letter in support from West102/12/2009View
176142Letter in support - Siatra102/12/2009View
177143Letter in concern - Lanyi102/12/2009View
178144Letter in support - Monahan102/12/2009View
179145Letter in opposition - Hecker202/12/2009View
180146DDOT report502/12/2009View
181147Letter in support - Merced102/12/2009View
182148Letter requesting hearing be postponed - Hamilton202/17/2009View
183149Letter in support from Higgins402/17/2009View
184150Letter in support - Mattison102/19/2009View
185151Letter in support - Strauss102/18/2009View
186152Letter in opposition - King and Stevens202/18/2009View
187153Notice of change in witness list submitted by Sullivan102/18/2009View
188154Letter in concern with attached letter to ANC last month1202/19/2009View
189155Affidavit of Maintenance2202/19/2009View
190156A1Applicant's PowerPoint (Part 1 of 4)1802/19/2009View
191156A2Applicant's PowerPoint (Part 2 of 4)1202/19/2009View
192156A3Applicant's PowerPoint (Part 3 of 4)2402/19/2009View
193156A4Applicant's PowerPoint (Part 4 of 4)1002/19/2009View
194157Witness list404/26/2012View
195158Witness cards404/26/2012View
196159Letter in support202/24/2009View
197160Letter in support from Coalition for Smarter Growth202/24/2009View
198161Cover letter enclosing resume of McGrath, Jr.202/26/2009View
199162Letter in support - SMD 3C07203/09/2009View
200163Letter in support - Flippen103/13/2009View
201164Applicant's cover letter enclosing powerpoint603/18/2009View
202165Expert witness resume from Haines303/26/2009View
203166DDOT report204/03/2009View
204167Request to give oral testimony from Sdafani104/03/2009View
205168OP powerpoint1304/06/2009View
206169Witness lists504/26/2012View
207170Testimony from Mendelson204/06/2009View
208171Witness cards1 View
209172Memo of approval from DC Fire Marshall104/08/2009View
210173Comments from Cleveland Park Citizens Association (CPCA)204/14/2009View
211174Submission by CPCA of Letter of Agreement between OP and CPCA from '021704/14/2009View
212175Statement in Opposition by Wisconsin Newark Neigh. CoalitionBook04/14/2009View
213175AStatement in Opposition by Wisconsin Newark Neigh. Coalition Tab ABook04/14/2009View
214175BStatement in Opposition by Wisconsin Newark Neigh. Coalition Tab BBook04/14/2009View
215175CStatement in Opposition by Wisconsin Newark Neigh. Coalition Tab CBook04/14/2009View
216176A1Traffic Study/Peer Review (Part 1 of 2)9004/17/2009View
217176A2Traffic Study/Peer Review (Part 2 of 2)68 View
218177Certificate of Service104/17/2009View
219178Order and time of testimony for April 23104/17/2009View
220179Letter in opposition from 2Amys (Peter Pastan)404/20/2009View
221180ANC 3C's Resolution in Support204/21/2009View
222181Francis Sclafani's photocopies to be reviewed during her 10 -minute testimony1004/22/2009View
223182Cleveland Park Citizens Association's request to withhold decision re: PUD304/22/2009View
224183Letter in opposition from Thomas Jandl104/23/2009View
225184DDOT Report304/23/2009View
226185Letter in support from Jane S. & Richard E. Jones104/23/2009View
227186Letter in Opposition submitted by Tom Haines104/23/2009View
228187Testimony of Judd Walenclkowski404/23/2008View
229188Letter in support from Eleanor Oliver304/23/2009View
230189Testimony of Jeffrey Davis, AWARE604/23/2009View
231190Testimony of Anne Large, AWARE204/23/2009View
232191Testimony of Laurence J. Aurbach, President, Woodland Normanstone Neighborhood Assoc.104/23/2009View
233192Testimony of Trudy Reeves, ANC 3C06104/23/2009View
234193Testimony of Genie Grohman, Chesterfield Cooperative204/23/2009View
235194Testimony of Richard Hage, Washington Interfaith Network204/23/2009View
236195Testimony of Robert Kerr204/23/2009View
237196Witness List604/23/2009View
238197Testimnoy of Nancy MacWood ANC 3C09404/23/2009View
239198Testimony of Serena Viswanathan104/23/2009View
240199Testimony of Cheryl Cort, Coalition for Smarter Growth104/23/2009View
241200Letter in Support from Madelyn Spirnak104/23/2009View
242201Testimony of Tad Baldwin, Ward 3 Vision304/23/2009View
243202Testimony of Leila Afzal104/23/2009View
244203Testimony of Ellen McCarthy404/23/2009View
245204Testimony of Allan Mendelsohn204/23/2009View
246205Testimony of Claire Bloch204/23/2009View
247206Testimony of 3300 Idaho Party1904/23/2009View
248207Friendship Shopping Center Traffic Study Peer Review by Precision Systems, Inc.1904/23/2009View
249208Witness Cards7 View
250209Letter in Support from Neil O. Albert104/24/2009View
251210Testimony of Rosalyn P. Doggett104/28/2009View
252211Signature in Support1704/28/2009View
253212Letter in Support from Leah Thayer104/29/2009View
254213Letter from Councilmember Kwame Brown in Support304/30/2009View
255214Idaho party's request of an independent and comprehensive evaluation of the transportation issues405/04/2009View
256215Letter in support from Barry Hoodem205/04/2009View
257216Letter in support from Leah Thayer105/04/2009View
258217Comments submitted by Lindsley Williams205/04/2009View
259218Letter from Caroline Michael Osborne105/04/2009View
260219Letter in support from Laura Cope1 (fax)05/04/2009View
261220Presentation/Testimony by CPCA (Cleveland Park Citizens Association)10 05/04/2009View
262221Photos submitted by CPCA305/04/2009View
263222Testimony of the Ordway Street Neighbors1805/04/2009View
264223Power Point presentation by John Korbel1805/04/2009View
265224Testimony of John Korbel2105/04/2009View
266225Testimony of James Pickman205/04/2009View
267226WNNC Power Point presentation (John O'Sullivan)1505/04/2009View
268227WNNC Testimony on Traffic Issues2005/04/2009View
269228Testimony of Alice Leccese Powers705/04/2009View
270229Testimony of Stephen Ives and Jean Emery205/04/2009View
271230Statement of JayEtta Hecker1105/04/2009View
272231Testimony of Margaret Lenzner705/04/2009View
273232Testimony of Ross Ain305/04/2009View
274233Testimony of Diane Olsson605/04/2009View
275234Presentation by Tom Graham805/04/2009View
276235Testimony of Wil Kohl205/04/2009View
277236Memo from Wells and Assoc. Review of PSI's Traffic study Peer Review1005/04/2009View
278237Witness Cards4 (2-sided) View
279238Letter in Support from Kwame Brown205/06/2009View
280239Cover letter enclosing powerpoint slides605/11/2009View
281240Letter in Support from Michael A. Brown205/11/2009View
282241Letter in opposition from Rudolf Bertrang205/11/2009View
283242Letter in concern from Gretta Chemali205/19/2009View
284243Letter in concern from Diane L. Olsson305/20/2009View
285244Letter in concern from Douglas R. Horne305/20/2009View
286245Statement of Philip Olsson305/20/2009View
287246Investigation from Institute of Transportation Engineers Trip Generation Handbook 2nd Edition1905/20/2009View
288247Letter clarifying a few issues submitted by Peter Pastan505/20/2009View
289248Newark St. Neighbors letter in concern505/20/2009View
290249Letter in concern Nancy J. MacWood re: applicant's LEED cert.305/20/2009View
291250Letter from Nancy MacWood re: two new building designs605/20/2009View
292251Letter from Nancy MacWood re: community meetings505/20/2009View
293252Letter from Institute of Transportation re: table A (daily truck stops)205/20/2009View
294253Letter in concern from 3300 Block of Idaho Party805/20/2009View
295254Testimony of Rochelle Kainer105/20/2009View
296254Testimony of Kainer105/20/2009View
297255Letter from applicant addressing ltr. from Diane Olsson + J. O'Sullivan re: Section 2405.6205/20/2009View
298256A1Applicant's Rebuttal Power Point Presentation (Part 1 of 3)1505/20/2009View
299256A2Applicant's Rebuttal Power Point Presentation (Part 2 of 3)1905/20/2009View
300256A3Applicant's Rebuttal Power Point Presentation (Part 3 of 3)1305/20/2009View
301257Applicant's response to Wisconsin-Newark Neighborhood Coalition's 4/14/09 Brief1905/20/2009View
302258Letter from MaryAnn O. Nash in opposition505/20/2009View
303259Witness Cards2 05/20/2009View
304260Applicant's Cover letter enclosing proposed findings of fact and conclusion of law3606/01/2009View
305261Proposed finding of facts submitted by Cleveland Park Citizens Assoc. incomplete copy1906/01/2009View
306262John O'Sullivan's cover letter enclosing proposed finding of facts6006/01/2009View
307263Proposed finding of facts submitted by John O'Sullivan6305/02/2009View
308264Mr. 0' Sullivan's cover letter enclosing section "traffic impacts"1006/03/2009View
309265Referral to NCPC1 View
310266Post-hearing submission607/02/2009View
311267Letter in support from ANC/SMD 3C07 - RETURNED207/06/2009View
312268Letter from Phil Mendelson requesting the applicant reconsider the design of supermarket RETURNED207/06/2009View
313269Letter from ANC 3C requesting the plan be revised RETURNED207/12/2009View
314270Letter requesting mitigation for noise from Diane OIson RETURNED207/13/2009View
315271Letter in support from Barbara Hindin RETURNED207/13/2009View
316272NCPC Report3 (fax)07/13/2009View
317274Supplemental OP Report207/13/2009View
318275Letter from Kwame Brown requesting relocating loading dock RETURNED207/15/2009View
319276Letter in support from Councilmember Mary Cheh RETURNED407/15/2009View
320277Letter in opposition from Carmela Veneroso RETURNED207/14/2009View
321278Letter in support from Joe Pinder RETURNED207/14/2009View
322279NCPC Report1007/16/2009View
323280Letter in opposition from James H. Hulme107/31/2009View
324281DC Register: ZC Order3408/14/2009View
325282Attestation: ZC Order3408/10/2009View
326283Applicant's motion to reconsider408/20/2009View
327284Receipt of zoning letter denying request to reopen the file208/24/2009View
328285Answers to Applicanfs Motion to Reconsider submitted by Diane L. Olsson1008/27/2009View
329286Answer to Applicant's Motion to Reconsider submitted by Phillip Montalto208/27/2009View
330287Opposition to Winners motion for reconsideration509/03/2009View
331288Corrected letter with returned letter to Barbara Hindin3 View
332289Copy of petition for review3809/14/2009View
333290Copy of petition for review submitted by John B. O'Sullivan309/11/2009View
334291Notice to Intervene509/28/2009View
335292Recommendations for revisions to condition 8(b) - off peak hours710/09/2009View
336293WNNC proposal to substitute for existing condition 8 b310/09/2009View
337294Order 08-15A to Register6 View
338295Attestation: Order 08-15A7 View
339296Letter of issues and concerns submitted by Daniel Hecker312/20/2010View
340297Decision of the District Court of Appeals2601/19/2012View
341298ZC Order No. 08-153402/19/2010View
Orders
OrdersAction
ZC Order No. 08-15View
Transcripts
Transcript DateMeeting TypeAction
10/19/2009Public MeetingView
10/01/2009Special Public MeetingView
09/14/2009Public MeetingView
07/13/2009Public MeetingView
06/08/2009Public HearingView
05/20/2009Public HearingView
05/04/2009Public HearingView
04/23/2009Public HearingView
04/06/2009Public HearingView
02/19/2009Public HearingView
09/08/2008Public MeetingView
07/28/2008Special Public MeetingView
Videos
Related Videos
We could not found any videos. Click here to search for past hearings by using DCOZ Video On Demand tool.
DC Office of Zoning
Office of Zoning

[email protected]
Office of Planning
Office of Planning

[email protected]
ANC
3C
JANELL MARIE PAGATS
Visit Website
SMD